Contents
|
Book 1--Bogus Purchases/Fake Invoices-Income Tax Aspects |
|
Part I--Addition Towards Bogus Purchases |
1. |
Addition on Account of Unexplained Expenditure--Law Regarding |
|
Applicability of section 69C |
|
Conditions precedent for applicability of section 69C |
|
Non-allowability of unexplained expenditure |
|
Scope of 'unexplained expenditure' in the context of section 69C |
|
Onus to prove existence of expenditure not explained |
|
Preference to be given to recorded expenditure |
|
Expenditure allegedly not where recorded in books |
|
No addition where no defect in books |
|
Addition cannot be made on basis of suspicion |
|
No addition in the absence of any corroborative evidence |
|
No addition on basis of statements of third party |
|
Addition on account of purchase of rough diamonds |
|
Allegedly bogus expenditure |
|
Year of addition |
|
Section 69C vis-a-vis section 37(1) |
|
Extent of addition towards undisclosed purchases |
|
Purchase from hawala dealers--Genuineness thereof |
|
Alleged unexplained expenditure on gems and jewellery |
|
Genuineness of sundry creditors where found doubtful |
|
Unexplained investment in stock-in-trade detected during survey |
|
Unexplained expenditure in purchase of materials |
|
Bogus purchases of machinery and interest on borrowed funds |
|
Alleged double taxation |
|
Addition on account of difference in amount payable to creditor as per assessee's books and as per books of creditor |
|
Expenditure recorded on a date later than on which it was incurred |
|
Addition to be made in hands of right person |
|
Addition based on jotting on seized paper |
|
Only parties from whom those purchases being made, were disputed--Entire purchases cannot be disallowed |
|
Where assessee could not produce creditors |
|
Purchases alleged as bogus--Assessee furnished supportive evidences |
|
Where purchases were genuine but recorded in fictitious names |
2. |
Addition Towards Bogus Purchases--Principles Regarding |
|
Prologue |
|
Where source of purchases not explained |
|
Where purchases not included in books of account |
|
Where assessee proved factum of purchases |
|
Purchases where duly reflected in books of accounts cannot be treated as bogus |
|
Purchases properly recorded in books |
|
Where purchases were supported by proper invoices duly reflected in books of account |
|
Failure to explain one-to-one relationship between alleged purchases and corresponding sales |
|
Non-service of summons issued under section 131 |
|
Opportunity of cross-examination where not afforded to assessee |
|
Purchase from hawala dealers--Genuineness thereof |
|
Genuineness of purchases could not be doubted where supplier provided all details |
|
Bogus purchases not proved by revenue--Addition on that count deleted |
|
Addition on the ground of bogus purchases cannot be made where gross profit rate had already been applied |
|
Default on part of State suppliers not to result in bogus purchases |
|
Additions to income towards bogus purchases where only secondary evidences were made available by assessee and primary evidence like purchase bills not produced |
|
Addition to income towards bogus purchases where assessee was engaged into dealings in grey market |
|
Mere denial under section 133(6) not to affect purchases |
|
Purchases alleged as bogus--Reasoning, assessee had not furnished bank statement of supplier and notices served by AO under section 133(6) were returned back by the postal authorities but assessee produced bills on which GST was made |
|
Where there was high volume of transactions, assessee was justified in producing sample purchases vouchers |
|
Unverified purchases |
|
Purchases from party accepted as genuine in earlier years |
|
Where assessee proved genuineness of purchases with documentary evidences --Purchases made through an agent |
|
Where supplier appeared before assessing officer and admitted that they had sold the goods to the assessee |
|
Where purchases proved to be genuine |
|
Assessee failed to prove genuineness of purchases |
|
Bogus purchases by accommodating entries |
|
Addition towards bogus purchases only on basis of suspicion |
|
Addition towards difference in purchase made without any evidence |
|
Addition only on basis of statement of third party |
|
Addition only on basis of statement given by third parties to sales tax department |
|
Where no hearing provided |
|
Non-appearance of supplier but assessee producing supporting documents |
|
Where identity of suppliers established |
|
Where quantitative tally of sales was furnished |
|
Addition only on basis of information from sales tax department/excise department |
|
No addition merely because seller declared as hawala dealer |
|
Assessee failed to prove genuineness of transaction of bogus purchase--Entire amount to be added |
|
Nature and source of purchase explained by assessee |
|
No proof that amount returned back to assessee |
|
Addition on account of allegedly unverifiable purchases |
|
Where assessee produced all details |
|
Transactions in question accepted to be genuine in group case of assessee--Same cannot be treated as bogus in assessee's hands |
|
Treating purchases as bogus where notice not responded to |
|
No dispute as regards corresponding sales--Assessee engaged in the business of trading of Air handling units, dust collectors and other ancillary labour jobs |
|
If bogus purchase to be disallowed then corresponding sale also to be disallowed |
|
Entire purchases treated as bogus without disputing corresponding sales |
|
Assessee engaged in manufacturing and sale of diamond studded gold jewellery--No dispute as regards corresponding sales |
|
No dispute as regards corresponding sales--Assessee engaged in trading of ferrous and non-ferrous metals |
|
No dispute as regards corresponding sales--Gross profit rate of 12.5% to be adopted |
|
When AO had accepted the sales then he ought to have given the benefit of purchase against the sales |
|
AO relied upon third party statement without supplying it to assessee--No addition possible |
|
Assessee furnished sworn affidavit of suppliers and also furnished documentary evidence in the form of purchase bills, sales tax return, income-tax returns of said parties--No addition was justified |
|
Allegation of reducing profit by obtaining non-genuine bogus purchase bills not proved by revenue |
|
Where AO made due inquiries but the ITAT deleted addition wrongly |
|
Where no inquiry made from the suppliers |
|
Commodity stock trading loss--Treatment of loss as bogus on suspicion basis--Necessary evidences filed by assessee |
|
Whether the transactions were bogus or not, cannot be a pure question of fact having regard to the evidence on record--Genuineness of transactions |
|
Where assessee had filed all relevant details like copies of bills, bank statements and delivery challans |
|
Assessee filed relevant documents, details to prove genuineness of purchases and payments were through banking channel--Addition permissible |
|
Where assessee furnished ledger accounts, purchase invoice, bank statements, etc.--Addition to be restricted |
|
Assessee made purchases from grey market--CIT(A) disallowed part of purchases |
|
Purchases treated as bogus on account of non-production of suppliers before AO |
|
Assessee already declared profit on account of sales against bogus purchase which was more than GP rate declared by assessee |
|
AO made addition based on third party statement recorded by Investigation Wing--No opportunity of cross-examination afforded to assessee |
|
Addition towards bogus purchases only on third party information--Where consumption of material is not doubted |
|
Addition on presumption that purchase transactions were bogus |
|
Merely, non-producing the parties in person despite knowing that those parties were identified parties--Addition cannot be made |
|
Alleged non-genuine purchases vis-a-vis entry operators confirmed having not supplied goods--Matter remanded for cross-verification |
|
Tentative and provisional figures shown by assessee as per Sales Tax Department in absence of any verification or audit by Sales Tax Department |
|
Loss claimed by assessee on commodity trading--AO held that transactions were not genuine and in order to show the loss from rice trading activity, it was fabricated loss to avoid taxes |
|
Where no incriminating material with AO as to bogus purchases--No addition possible |
|
Entire bogus purchase to be disallowed where assessee failed to prove alleged bogus purchases had either found its way as a part of accounted sales or formed part of closing stock--Assessee-HUF was engaged in business of trading in iron and steel |
|
Both sales and purchases claimed by assessee were mere book entries--AO made addition in assessee's hands on account of bogus sales only |
|
Assessee filed complete books of accounts, items-wise stock register and also produced copies of bank statements evidencing payments through banking channels to suppliers--No addition possible |
|
Where supplier admitted before AO that he did not provide any accommodation entry--No addition permissible |
|
Addition towards bogus creditors where purchases not verified |
|
Where suppliers did not respond to notices under section 133(6) but no fault found in assessee's documents |
|
Restriction of addition, where construction of statute favour the assessee |
|
Application of NP rate--Assessee indulged in providing bogus accommodation entries |
|
Purchase not to be disallowed merely because made from sister concern |
|
No opportunity provided to the assessee to cross-examine parties providing accommodation entries |
|
Assessee produced bills raised by all parties and in some cases credit notes given by the said parties before AO but failed to produce any evidence to prove that there was physical movement of goods--Addition restricted to gross profit |
|
Where supplier retracted from his statement later on and assessee placed documentary evidences |
|
Addition on account of bogus purchases--Assessee failed to appear before AO to substantiate his case |
|
Loss on purchase and sale of skimmed milk powder and Channa not proved |
|
Where assessee had made huge cash purchases from traders (other than farmers) under the head 'Milk Purchase Tanki' |
|
Where purchases of gold would not be proved by AO to be of bogus purchases |
|
Where assessee filed ledger confirmation and PAN of suppliers |
|
Bogus purchases--Addition for same amount already made by AO in case of company promoted by assessee |
|
Where addition towards bogus purchases made by AO after due enquiries |
|
Purchases made by assessee being not in dispute--Only parties from whom those purchases being made, were disputed |
3. |
Bogus Purchases--Incidental Issues |
|
Addition towards commission on bogus purchases |
|
Benefit of telescoping and bogus purchases |
|
Purchased sale of gold coin in cash--Benefit of telescoping to be provided to assessee |
|
Commission income for providing accommodation entries--Case of bogus bill provider |
|
Bogus cash sales--AO did not doubt purchases made by assessee |
|
Letter of credit (LC) charges pertaining to alleged bogus purchases claimed as deduction against business income of other business activities |
|
Deduction under section 80-IA(4)(iii)--Allowability of--Profit of business enhanced by disallowance of bogus purchases and bogus expenses |
|
Unexplained creditors shown against purchases already subjected to addition under section 69C |
|
Assessee furnished invoice and sanction letter of bank, and bank certified that payments were made to vendors--Purchase of fixed asset |
4. |
Bogus Purchases--Addition of Only Profit Element |
|
Disallowance of only profit element embedded in bogus purchases instead of whole amount of purchases |
|
Where supplier confirmed transaction and assessee also furnished documentary evidences--Only profit element be added |
|
Bogus purchases--Only profit element to be added |
|
Where entire purchases proved to be bogus--Still profit element only to be added |
|
Assessee failed to prove purchases by documentary evidence--Still profit element only be added |
|
Estimation of income on account of bogus purchases |
|
Where sales made by assessee not doubted |
|
Where sales made by suppliers not doubted |
|
How gross profit on bogus purchases be determined |
|
Estimation of profit in arbitrary manner |
|
Gross profit rate on bogus purchases only can be added |
|
Where books not rejected--Only profit element can be added |
|
Purchases from hawala dealers--Only profit element can be added |
|
Where purchases made from hawala dealers but assessee submitted all the invoices in connection with the said parties and bank statement showing payment to such parties--Addition restricted to 12.5% of bogus purchases |
|
Assessee beneficiary of hawala entries--Addition restricted to profit element |
|
Undisclosed purchases--Only profit element be added |
|
Non-production of suppliers--But only profit element can be added |
|
Where suppliers cannot be produced still profit element be added |
|
Rate of profit restricted to 12.5%/5% on bogus purchase |
|
Restriction of addition to 12.5% |
|
CIT(A) sustained addition to 25% |
|
Purchase of diamonds from bogus suppliers where payment made via banking channels |
|
Alleged bogus purchases, where sales not doubted--Only profit element be added |
|
Estimation of profits on bogus purchases at 6% |
|
Sales made out of alleged purchases not being doubted by revenue--Addition restricted to 12.5% |
|
No dispute as to corresponding sales of tainted purchases-Addition restricted to 12.5% |
|
Where profit estimated at 9.5% |
|
Estimation of profits on bogus purchases at 13.7% |
|
Restriction of disallowance at 6.75% |
|
Rate of profit embedded in purchases estimated at 8% |
|
CIT(A) restricted addition made by AO to 3% as against 10% |
|
CIT(A) restricted the disallowance of purchases to 12.5% |
|
CIT(A) restricting addition made on account of non-genuine purchases at 12.5%--Assessee was a trader dealing in metal |
|
CIT(A) restricting the disallowance to 5% |
|
Where estimation made by CIT(A) appeared to be on higher side |
|
Addition @ 12.5% for embedded profit in transaction of bogus purchases |
|
Addition made on account of bogus purchase @3% on value of alleged bogus purchases--Assessee dealing in diamonds |
|
Assessee failed to discharge burden of establishing genuineness of purchases--Still addition be restricted to 12.5% |
|
Assessee being beneficiary of Hawala purchases--CIT(A) enhanced addition to 100% |
|
Assessee engaged in trading in ferrous and non-ferrous metals but assessee failed to provide purchase related documents--Addition restricted to 6% |
|
Sales being not doubted--Addition restricted 8% |
|
Purchases from grey market--Only profit element be added |
|
Restriction of addition on bogus purchases to 10% |
|
Restriction of addition |
|
Restriction of disallowance to 2% of total purchase |
|
AO disallowed an amount being 12.5% of alleged non-genuine purchases --But disallowance restricted to 5% |
|
Restriction of disallowance to 6% where assessee engaged in trading in rough and polished diamonds |
|
Where books were audited had produced the stock register and assessee all the payments had been made through banking channels--Restriction of disallowance to be at 20% |
|
Margin on alleged bogus purchases restricted |
|
Addition to be restricted to gross profit rate on other genuine purchases |
|
Where purchases made from hawala dealers but assessee submitted all the invoices in connection with the said parties and bank statement showing payment to such parties--Addition restricted to 12.5% of bogus purchases |
|
Where notices to suppliers under section 133(6) not responded--Still profit element be added |
|
Estimation of income on bogus purchases, where sales have not been doubted |
|
Information received by AO to the effect that assessee made bogus purchases from a party but assessee filed copy of ledger account of the said party in its books of account and also the purchase bills |
|
Addition on basis of information emanated from Sales-tax Department where there was no dispute as regards corresponding sales |
|
Addition towards bogus purchases be limited to gross profit margin |
|
Addition be restricted to gross profit rate on genuine purchases |
|
Estimation of profit embedded in bogus purchases where notice not responded by suppliers |
|
Notice to suppliers remain unresponded but sales being not disputed |
|
AO based on information emanated from Investigation Wing, treated purchases as bogus but no dispute as regards corresponding sales |
|
Assessee engaged in business of trading in ferrous and non ferrous metals and AO found assessee to be beneficiary of bogus purchases--Rate of profit restricted to 12.5% |
|
Purchases alleged as bogus on basis of information received from the Sales Tax Department--No dispute as regards corresponding sales |
|
Estimation of income where sales turnover accepted by AO |
|
Purchases disallowed only because notice under section 133(6) not responded to |
|
Alleged bogus purchase but sales being accepted |
|
No dispute as regards corresponding sales--Assessee-firm engaged in trading and export of gem stones, diamond, rough, etc. |
|
Where purchase transactions carried out by assessee with suspicious suppliers were evidenced by copies of invoices and payments were through banking channels--Only profit element be added |
|
Purchases treated as bogus on information emanated from investigation wing --No dispute as regards corresponding sales |
|
Notice under section 133(6) to suppliers returned unserved--Profit element be added--Where sales were accepted |
|
Only profit element to be added--Alleged bogus purchases |
|
Rate of margin on suspicious purchases |
|
Assessee-company was engaged in business of manufacturing and dealing in watches--Sales being not doubted |
|
Where existence of suppliers was not proved--Still addition be restricted |
|
Assessee engaged in business of diamonds--Assessee maintaining books of account and day to day stock register--Entire amount cannot be disallowed |
|
Where sales turnover was not in doubt and assessee was in possession of primary purchase documents--Only profit element to be added |
|
Assessee failed to produce bills/vouchers--Disallowance restricted because sales were not doubted |
|
Sales turnover not in doubt--Assessee was engaged as retailer of ferrous and non-ferrous metal |
|
Tribunal restricted the estimation of income to 4% bogus purchases |
|
Unverifiable purchases--Only profit element be added |
|
Assessee was engaged in business of dealing in laptop and its accessories --Sales being not doubted |
|
Assessee-firm engaged in business of government washing processing and stitching--No dispute as regards corresponding sales |
|
No dispute as regards corresponding sales--Addition restricted to gross profit on genuine purchases |
|
Purchases made from the non-existent vendors--Addition restricted |
|
Purchases alleged as bogus--AO had not doubted records, details and evidences i.e., purchases made by assessee, consumption, sales and stock reconciliations furnished by assessee |
|
Estimation of profit on the bogus purchases--Where supplier not available |
|
Assessee had taken accommodation entries of sales shown for Rs. 12,24,86,657 to earn unaccounted profit--Addition restricted to gross profit |
|
Where AO nowhere disputed purchases made and sales disclosed--Disallowance to be restricted |
|
Assessee was found to be beneficiary of providers of bogus purchase bills --AO taxed entire purchases |
|
No dispute as regards corresponding sales--Assessee being a trader suffered loss in trading activities |
|
Assessee engaged in trading of diamond and sales not being doubted |
5. |
Bogus Purchases and Addition Under Section 41(1) |
|
Chargeability of benefit obtained on remission or cessation of trading liability |
|
Remission or cessation of liability by way of unilateral act of parties also taxable |
|
Conditions precedent for applicability of provisions of section 41(1) |
|
What section 41(1) does not envisage |
|
Meaning and scope of remission or cessation of liability |
|
Amount written back to profit and loss account |
|
Non-subsisting liabilities of bogus creditors |
|
Addition of liability towards sundry creditors treated as bogus--Corresponding material purchases claim stood allowed by AO |
|
Where not even a single creditor has informed the assessing officer that the liability has been ceased/remitted |
|
Once purchases have been accepted the same amount cannot be added under section 41(1) in absence of cessation of liability |
|
Unexplained creditors--Assessee had shown that payment have been made through banking channels |
|
Liabilities towards bogus purchases discharged in succeeding years |
6. |
Disallowance of Cash Payments and Bogus Purchases |
|
Disallowance under section 40A(3) |
|
Subsequent disallowance due to violation of section 40A(3) in a year other than the year of allowance of deduction of expenses |
|
No disallowance even if payment made in cash exceeds Rs. 10,000 |
|
Does several payments made in a day to same person hit by section 40A(3) |
|
Provisions illustrated |
|
Crossed cheque versus account payee cheque |
|
Protection to payers making payment by way of crossed cheque, etc. |
|
Section 40A(3) calls for strict compliance |
|
When section 40A(3) applies |
|
How section 40A(3) be applied |
|
Section 40A(3) to be interpreted keeping in view its objects |
|
No cash payment exceeding Rs. 20,000 on any single day to any single person and genuineness of payments not in dispute |
|
None of cash payment in a day exceeded threshold limit of Rs. 20,000 |
|
Payment made by banker's cheques, pay order and call deposit receipt--Not hit by section 40A(3) |
|
Extent of disallowance under section 40A(3) |
|
Limiting of addition by applying profit element where genuineness of purchases are not doubted |
|
No proof that payment in cash exceeded specified limit |
7. |
Rejection of Accounts and Bogus Purchases |
|
Circumstances calling for rejection of accounts |
|
True profits reflected from accounts of the assessee--No rejection permissible |
|
Duty of revenue while rejecting books of accounts |
|
Books cannot be rejected without pointing out defect |
|
No discrepancy in books of account pointed out--Books cannot be rejected |
|
Books cannot be rejected on flimsy grounds |
|
When rejection of accounts be justified |
|
Clear-cut finding to be recorded for rejection of accounts |
|
Rejection of accounts to be on proper grounds |
|
Opportunity of being heard be provided |
|
Non-maintenance of stock records and rejection of books |
|
--Assessee not maintaining day to day stock register, closing stock inventory and sales were not vouched--Rejection justified |
|
--Accounting method rightly rejected where assessee did not produce stock records |
|
--Rejection justified where relevant documents not produced to verify closing stock |
|
--Non-production of stock register may lead rejection |
|
--Stock register not maintained--Assessee engaged in printing of lottery tickets |
|
--Assessee allegedly not having maintained quantitative stock details--No addition be made on estimate basis |
|
--Non-maintenance of quantitative records--Whether substantial question of law arose |
|
--Deficiencies in stock records--No suppression of sale outside books |
|
--Non-maintenance of day-to-day stock register--Effect of |
|
--Non-maintenance of stock register and quantitative details |
|
--Irregularity in maintaining books of account and non-maintenance of stock register |
|
--Stock register not maintained but ledger account showing details of stock |
|
--Mere non-maintenance of stock register not to result in rejection of account |
|
--Non-maintenance of stock register and closing stock adopted without any supporting document--Rejection justified |
|
--Stock hypothecated to bank but higher value declared--Rejection of books not justified |
|
Rejection of accounts--When held to be justified? |
|
Rejection of accounts--When held not justified? |
|
Bogus purchases and rejection of books |
|
Bogus purchases introduced by manufacturer of by-product--Addition justified |
|
Additions for bogus purchases cannot be made where all details about suppliers was furnished by assessee |
|
Low G.P. rate and defects in books of account--Books rightly rejected |
|
Information from Police Department as to bogus purchases not indicating name of assessee |
|
Assessee failed to discharge the onus to establish the genuineness of transactions |
|
Where there was only paper transactions during the year--Books were rightly rejected |
|
AO made addition by estimating profit on account of circular transaction |
|
Rejection of books of account on ground of bogus purchases |
|
AO did not reject books of account and also did not comment on genuineness of sales |
8. |
Duty of Assessee as to Proving Genuineness of Purchases |
9. |
Specimen Reply As to Alleged Bogus Purchases |
|
Part II--Search, Survey and Bogus Purchases |
10. |
Search Assessments and Bogus Purchases [Where Search Took Place Prior to 1-4-2021] |
|
Relevant provisions |
|
Scope of assessment under section 153A |
|
Addition to be based upon incriminating material found during search--Views of High Courts/ITAT Special Bench |
|
Past assessment cannot be disturbed where no incriminating documents or material found during search |
|
Where no incriminating material found to sustain statement made under 132(4) |
|
Where no incriminating material belonging to assessee found, no action under section 153C can be taken |
|
No incriminating material found during search, concluded assessments cannot be disturbed |
|
Decision in case of CIT & Anr. v. Kabul Chawla & Anr. 2015 TaxPub(DT) 3486 (Del-HC) |
|
Revenue not to get second opportunity |
|
Detection or the existence of incriminating material is a must for disturbing the assessment already made |
|
Object of section 153A only to assess undisclosed income |
|
Once notice is issued under section 153A all assessment get reopened--The contrary view |
|
Facts of the case in PR. CIT (Central) v. M/s. Delhi International Airport Pvt. Ltd., M/s. GMR Hyderabad International Airport Pvt. Ltd. 2022 TaxPub(DT) 6669 (Del-HC) |
|
No incriminating material found during search regarding bogus purchase--Unabated assessment cannot be disturbed |
|
Summing up |
11. |
Survey and Bogus Purchases |
|
A. POWER OF SURVEY [SECTION 133A] |
|
Places which can be surveyed |
|
Duties of persons available during survey |
|
Authorities eligible for conducting survey |
|
Power of Survey--Notified Income Tax Authority |
|
Requirement as to prior permission |
|
Timings for conducting surveys |
|
Powers of Inspector of Income Tax |
|
Powers to be exercised during survey, other than for TDS TCS purposes |
|
Meaning of "proceeding" |
|
Powers regarding impounding and retaining of books of accounts and other documents |
|
No power as to remove cash, stock and other valuable articles |
|
Power regarding survey at the time of functions and ceremonies |
|
No survey on third parties premises |
|
Tax not to be recovered during survey proceedings |
|
Authorities not supposed to force the person being surveyed to confess undisclosed income |
|
Availability of presumption under section 292C |
|
Exercise of power given under section 131(1) by surveying authorities |
|
Conversion of survey into search |
|
Differences between survey and search |
|
Evidentiary value of statement recorded under section 133A(3)(i) |
|
Impact of retraction of statement |
|
Addition on the basis of loose papers impounded |
|
Addition on account of excess stock |
|
Applicability of section 68, 69A, etc. in case of survey |
|
Excess stock to be assessed as business income |
|
Addition on account of unaccounted sales--No material evidence for unaccounted purchases for effecting unaccounted sales |
|
B. ASSESSMENT PROCEDURE IN CASE OF SURVEY CONDUCTED ON OR AFTER 1-4-2021 |
|
Applicability of section 147 in case of survey |
12. |
Purchases Made But Bills Not Received--Impact of Survey |
|
Issue |
|
Opinion |
13. |
Income Surrendered in Survey--Head of Income Applicable |
|
Income referred to in sections 68, 69, 69A, 69B, 69C and 69D to be taxed at flat rate of 60 per cent |
|
Income, except cash, surrendered during survey may be treated as business income |
|
Decision in Fakir Mohmed Haji Hasan v. CIT 2001 TaxPub(DT) 0551 (Guj-HC) : (2001) 247 ITR 0290 (Guj) : (2001) 165 CTR (Guj) 0111 : (2002) 120 Taxman 0011 (Guj) |
|
Decision in Fakir Mohmed Haji Hasan v. CIT 2001 TaxPub(DT) 0551 (Guj-HC) : (2001) 247 ITR 0290 (Guj) explained |
|
Income Surrendered in survey--Head of income applicable to surrendered income |
|
Excess stock found during survey surrendered as business income--Applicability of section 115BBE |
|
Summing up |
|
Part III--Incidental Issues to Bogus Purchases--Reassessment and Revision |
14. |
Bogus Purchases and Reassessment |
|
Power to assess or reassess |
|
Power to assess any other income also |
|
Reassessment subject to provisions of section 148 to section 153 |
|
Condition precedent for assuming jurisdiction under section 147 |
|
Conditions for reopening as per section 147 are jurisdictional fact and must be satisfied before issuance of notice under section 148 |
|
Steps to be followed for assuming jurisdiction under section 147 |
|
Prior approval of higher authorities in search, survey or requisition cases |
|
Substituted section 147 vis-a-vis erstwhile section 147 |
|
Nature and purpose of provisions under section 147 |
|
Words 'such income' refer to escaped income which is chargeable to tax |
|
Definite finding that income chargeable to tax has escaped assessment--Whether a necessity at stage of issuance of notice |
|
Invoking new section 147 in different situations |
|
Assessing officer to identify year of reassessment |
|
Jurisdiction when can validly be assumed |
|
Reopening on bogus purchases |
|
Reopening on information from investigation wing as to assessee having received accommodation entries of alleged bogus purchases |
|
Reopening based on investigation report--Assessee pleaded no conclusive proof as to tax escapement |
|
Where transaction itself on the basis of the subsequent information was found to be a bogus transactions |
|
Independent application of mind by AO to information emanated from Investigation Wing |
|
Reopening based on information emanated from VAT Department--No independent application of mind by AO |
|
Reopening based on reasons recorded in another cases--No independent application of mind by AO |
|
Reopening based on information emanated from investigation Wing--Non-application of mind by AO |
|
Information received from Investigation Wing of Department that certain income chargeable to tax had escaped assessment |
|
Reopening based on third party information--Non-application of mind by AO |
|
Reopening on basis of allegation of bogus purchases but assessee pleading that he made sales instead |
|
Assessee pleaded that AO reopened case of assessee on the basis of third party information without live-link between reasons recorded qua the assessee |
|
Purchases alleged as bogus based on investigation report--No indepen-dent investigation by AO and no dispute as regards corresponding sales |
|
Reopening based on information received by AO from CIB--No independent application of mind by AO |
|
Issuance of notice solely relying on investigation report--No independent application of mind by AO |
|
Reopening based on investigation report--Assessee pleaded that there was no specific information about the accommodation entry availed of by assessee |
|
AO received information after scrutiny assessment that assessee was beneficiary of bogus entries |
|
AO not having mechanically relied on the third party information and proceedings being initiated after verification and inquiry |
|
Entire purchase cannot be brought to tax |
|
Reopening based on investigation report--Bogus purchases--No tangible material found to form an opinion that income chargeable to tax had escaped assessment |
|
Restriction of disallowance |
|
Reopening based on Investigation Report--Reason to believe--Bogus purchase --Assessee argued that reasons recorded by AO were not in accordance with the scheme of section 147 |
|
Unrecorded purchases and reassessment |
|
Where no bills produced by assessee |
15. |
Conducting Inquiry and Providing Opportunity of Hearing before Issuance of Show-Cause Notice under Section 148 |
|
Recording of reason and supply thereof--Now embedded in section 148A |
|
Procedure before issuing notice for reassessment under section 148 |
|
Procedure under section 148A--When applicable |
|
Where no need to follow procedure as per section 148A |
|
Specified authority for purpose of section 148A |
|
Steps to be taken before issuance of notice under section 148 |
|
Whether charge of escapement of income in notice under section 148A is mandatory |
|
Procedure for invoking reassessment jurisdiction--In nutshell |
|
Relevance of proceedings under section 148A |
|
Existence of information necessary for issuance of notice under section 148A |
|
When notice under section 148A can be issued |
|
Inquiries that may be conducted under section 148A(a) |
|
Scope of enquiry under section 148A(a) |
|
Enquiry in respect of Explanation 1(ii) of section 148 |
|
Limitation on inquiry |
|
Scope of approval |
|
Requirement of putting up all material before specified authority |
|
Issuance of show cause notice (SCN) under section 148A(b) |
|
Opportunity of hearing to assessee |
|
Requirement as to separate SCN for each assessment year involved |
|
Show cause notices--Pre-conditions as to |
|
All relied upon document to be attached |
|
Use of materials against the assessee |
|
Show-cause notice to be specific |
|
What shall be contents of show cause notice |
|
Consideration of assessee's reply and passing of order |
|
Passing of order under section 148A(d) |
|
Assessing officer to consider material on record |
|
Section 148A and survey cases |
16. |
New Scheme of Section 148A and Judgments of High Courts |
|
New scheme of reassessment explained |
|
New scheme of reassessment explained in Divya Capital One (P) Ltd. v. Asstt. CIT & Anr. 2022 TaxPub(DT) 3427 (Del-HC) |
|
Delhi High Court judgment in Fena (P) Ltd. v. ACIT & Anr. 2022 TaxPub(DT) 3444 (Del-HC) |
|
Where partnership stood dissolved but bank account contained details of firm --Transaction in bank duly reflected in proprietorship firm formed pursuant to dissolution |
|
Where statutory period of seven days not given |
|
Where assessee does not object to period provided being less than seven days |
|
Change in allegation in notice under section 148A(b) and order under section 148A(d) |
|
Undue haste in passing the order under section 148A(d) and cost also imposed on AO |
|
Adequate time limit to be provided |
|
Decision of Delhi High Court in First Solar Power India (P) Ltd. v. Asstt. CIT & Anr. 2022 TaxPub(DT) 3720 (Del-HC) |
|
--Information culled out from assessee's records without mentioning as to what is wrong in these transactions--Cannot be ground to reopen |
|
--Reply of assessee to be considered |
|
Reply of assessee to be considered |
|
On facts, case was not perfect to be reopened but still notice issued--Action initiated against assessing officer |
|
Change in stand from allegation of bogus purchase to bogus sales |
|
Relied upon material not provided to assessee |
|
Adjournment as prayed for not granted |
|
Assessing officer to consider material on record |
|
Decision to issue notice under section 148 cannot be called in question in writ |
|
Assessee pleaded that AO without application of mind, without considering the material placed on record and reply, mechanically passed the order under section 148A |
|
Reopening based on investigation report--Assessee pleaded that there was no specific information about the accommodation entry availed of by assessee |
|
Order under section 148A(d) passed on conjectures and surmises |
|
Where last date to reply fell on public holiday |
17. |
Notice under Section 148 |
|
Service of notice before making reassessment |
|
Conditions precedent for issuance of notice |
|
No need for prior approval from specified authority where order under section 148A has been passed with such prior approval |
|
Information when can be said to be suggestive of escapement |
|
Deemed information in possession |
|
Scope of deemed information |
|
Notice when cannot be issued after three years under new law |
|
Steps to be taken for issuance of notice under section 148 |
|
Conditions precedent for issue and service of notice under section 148 |
|
Whether it is necessary to attach reasons with notice why procedure under section 148A has not been followed |
|
Distinction between Explanation 1 and Explanation 2 to section 148 |
|
Return not filed within time specified in notice--Effect of |
18. |
Information as Basis for Reopening |
|
When notice under section 148 can be issued |
|
Information when can be said to be suggestive of escapement |
|
Some instances of information that can be obtained through RMS |
|
Risk management strategies |
|
How information will be flagged |
|
What constitutes information |
|
Information from ITS system of department cannot solely be ground for reopening |
|
Reopening based on incorrect information--Non-application of mind by authorities |
|
No application of mind by AO to information forming basis for reopening |
|
Concluding remarks |
19. |
Time Limit for Reopening of Assessment |
|
Related provisions |
|
Provisions in brief |
|
Conditions for invoking section 149(1)(a) |
|
Conditions for invoking section 149(1)(b) |
|
Interplay between section 149(1)(a) and 149(1)(b) |
|
Conditions for issuance of notice under section 149(1A) |
|
Amendments by Finance Bill, 2023 |
|
Extended Time limit under new section 149--Whether available for past years |
|
What constitutes asset for the purposes of section 149(1)(b) |
|
Notices which can be issued in search cases |
|
--Notice under section 148 and effect of proviso (Normal cases plus survey cases) |
|
--Notice under section 148 and effect of proviso (Person searched and other person except where income represented in form of asset, etc. is or likely not to exceed Rs. 50 lakhs) |
|
--Notice under section 148 and effect of proviso (Person searched and other person where income represented in form of asset,etc. is or likely to exceed Rs. 50 lakhs) |
|
No notice under section 148 where search conducted upto 31-3-2021 |
|
Exclusion of certain time limits |
|
Requirement as to issuance of notice for each assessment year where escaped income referred to in section 149(1)(b) pertains to more than one previous year |
|
Non-applicability of time limit provided under section 149 where assessment is in pursuance of an appeal order |
|
Time limit for issuance of notice under section 148 effective from 1-4-2021--At a glance |
|
Instances where reassessment cannot be made after three years even if there is escapement of income |
|
Time limit for issuance of notice as existed upto 31-3-2021 |
|
Applicability of section 149(1) and effect of first proviso to section 149(1) |
|
Where alleged escaped income does not exceed Rs. 50,00,000 and time limit for reopening |
20. |
Procedure for Reassessment Where Search or Requisition Initiated on or after 1-4-2021 |
|
Search undertaken on or after 1-4-2021 and assessment procedure |
|
Procedure for assessment under section 147 |
|
No requirement to follow proceedings provided under section 148A in search and requisition cases |
|
Concept of deemed information in search and requisition cases |
|
Issuance of notice under section 148 |
|
Issues regarding notice under section 148 in search cases |
|
Search initiated on or before 31-3-2021 |
|
Reopening of all assessment years not required |
|
Issues likely to arise |
|
Provisions of section 148A not to be applied |
|
Reopening where income escaping assessment is represented by any asset, expenditure, entry, etc. |
|
Jurisdiction over other than searched person |
|
Whether proposition that incriminating material must be found as a result of search is a must under new law also |
|
Search cases and scope of reassessment |
|
Prior approval for assessment, reassessment or recomputation in search, requisition and survey cases |
|
Search assessment under section 153A vis-a-vis under new procedure |
|
Salient features of new procedure for search assessment |
21. |
Reassessment Procedure in Case of Survey Conducted on or after 1-4-2021 |
|
Applicability of section 147 in case of survey |
|
Issuance of show cause notice under section 148A before issuance of notice for reassessment under section 148 |
|
Issuance of notice |
|
Prior approval for assessment, reassessment or recomputation in search, requisition and survey cases |
|
Information when can be said to suggestive of escapement |
|
Requirement as to incriminating material for issuance of notice under section 148 in survey cases |
|
Deemed 'information' in possession in case of survey |
|
Survey cases and reassessment |
22. |
Revision and Bogus Purchases |
|
Revision of an order passed by the assessing officer |
|
Under what circumstances, order passed by assessing officer can be revised under section 263 |
|
Orders that can be revised under section 263 |
|
Pre-requisites for exercising power of revision under section 263 |
|
Commissioner to point out the exact error in the order to be revised, while providing opportunity to assessee |
|
Intimation under section 143(1)(a) cannot be revised under section 263 |
|
Invocation of jurisdiction on the basis of audit objection |
|
Faceless revision |
|
Faceless effect of orders |
|
Meaning of 'record' for the purposes of section 263 |
|
Order passed by the assessing officer deemed to be erroneous in so far as it is prejudicial to the interest of the revenue |
|
Order passed by assessing officer which is not erroneous but is prejudicial to the assessee cannot be revised under section 263 |
|
Assessment order passed in accordance with the guidelines issued by the CBDT cannot be said to be erroneous |
|
Commissioner need not to state the manner in which he considered that order of AO was erroneous and prejudicial to revenue and the basis of such conclusion |
|
Failure to initiate penalty proceeding at the time of passing of assessment order does not render the order erroneous |
|
Order passed by AO cannot be said to be erroneous where he adopts one possible view out of two |
|
Revision under section 263 is not permissible where AO takes one of the possible views |
|
Order which is not prejudicial to interest of revenue cannot be revised under section 263 |
|
Action under section 263 cannot be taken where assessing officer made proper enquiries |
|
Order passed by the AO cannot be be said to erroneous where he passed an order after considering the relevant facts and provisions of law |
|
Where only one item in the assessment order is found prejudicial to the interest of revenue |
|
Order erroneous where the AO did not apply the correct law |
|
Revision proceeding initiated only on the basis of audit objection not sustainable |
|
Lack of proper enquiry render order passed by assessing officer erroneous |
|
Order passed by the assessing officer getting reopened, not erroneous |
|
Where assessing officer has followed order of higher appellate authorities |
|
Assessing officer's order passed after necessary enquiry--Whether erroneous and prejudicial order |
|
Failure to make elaborate discussion in the assessment order would not render the order erroneous |
|
CIT asking AO for further enquiry and de novo assessment |
|
Where AO had taken a judicial view |
|
Invocation of jurisdiction for expending the jurisdiction of AO to examine issues beyond the scope of limited scrutiny |
|
Assessing officer took a possible view |
|
No lack of enquiry on AO's part |
|
Estimation of additional profit at the rate of 11.27% towards bogus purchases by AO--Addition of amount of difference between gross profit rate on genuine purchase and on hawala purchase |
|
Possible view taken by AO on account of bogus purchases |
|
AO took plausible view and added only 20% of bogus purchases |
|
Adequate enquiries carried by AO as to issue of bogus purchases |
|
Where AO added only 8% of turnover but PCIT alleged that 100% of purchases be added |
|
Disputed issue as to bogus purchases has been examined in detail in assessment proceedings--Reasonable view taken by AO and treated 12.5% of purchases as issue |
|
Where AO examined issue of bogus purchases and added 2.82% of the total purchases but CIT directed AO to consider the addition @ 12.5% of the bogus purchases |
|
Kind of orders that can be passed under section 263 |
|
Procedure required to be followed |
|
Necessity of granting opportunity of being heard |
|
Commissioner not providing opportunity of hearing to assessee--Validity of revision |
|
Necessary to record satisfaction before issuance of the show-cause notice |
|
CIT cannot give direction to the assessing officer to complete the assessment following a particular procedure |
|
Jurisdiction to revise an assessment order which was made subject matter of appeal before Commissioner (Appeals) |
|
Invocation of jurisdiction--Appeal pending before CIT(A) |
|
Invocation of jurisdiction in respect of issue decided in-appeal by CIT(A) |
|
Commissioner to record basis on which he deems that order passed AO is erroneous and prejudicial to the interest of the revenue |
|
Commissioner cannot initiate proceeding under section 263 merely on the ground that the enquiry conducted by the assessing officer was inadequate |
|
Revision on the basis of fresh facts or any subsequent event |
|
Powers under section 263 cannot be used for directing a re-verification |
|
While making fresh assessment in pursuance of revisional order under section 263, the assessing officer is not entitled to examine the items which did not form part of revisional proceedings |
|
Lack of natural justice on part of PCIT |
|
Time-limit for exercise of power of revision |
|
When time limit of two years for passing of revisional order would not apply |
|
Limitation where reassessment order is sought to be revised |
|
Limitation where original assessment order is rectified under section 154 |
|
Initial order passed under section 143(3)--Fresh order passed on directions of CIT(A)--Reckoning of limitation period |
|
Bar of limitation--Issue pertained to original assessment and not the reopened assessment |
|
Remedy available to assessee against order passed by Principal Commissioner or Commissioner under section 263 |
|
Consequential validity of assessment order |
|
Invocation of second time revisional jurisdiction |
|
Assessment order being void ab initio treated as erroneous by CIT |
|
Part IV--Tax Consequences of Addition Towards Bogus Purchases as Income From Undisclosed Sources |
23. |
Taxation at Special Rate under Section 115BBE |
|
Section 115BBE as currently applicable |
|
Impact of introducing section 115BBE |
|
Substitution of sub-section (1) by Taxation Laws (Second Amendment) Act, 2016 to provide higher rate of tax |
|
Effective tax rate under section 115BBE |
|
Clarification regarding set off of losses against deemed undisclosed income |
|
Amendment denying set-off of losses whether applicable prospectively or retrospectively |
|
Applicability of enhanced rate of 60 per cent |
|
Levy of penalty under section 271AAC |
|
Applicability of section 115BBE to all assessees |
|
Provision under section 115BBE whether compensatory in nature |
|
Applicability of provision without any threshold |
|
Assessee eligible to reflect deemed income even in a belated or revised return |
|
Income chargeable under section 115BBE required to be reported in ITR as income from other sources |
|
Assessee need not to include income likely to be deemed under sections 68 to 69D |
|
Section 115BBE not to be applied by invoking rectification provision under section 154 |
|
Allowability of set-off of unabsorbed depreciation |
|
Set off of business loss out of unexplained income |
|
Set-off of share trading business loss against cash credit |
|
No set off of losses consequent to search, requisition and survey |
|
Section 115BBE(2) vis-a-vis section 79A |
24. |
Unexplained Income Liable to Taxation under Section 115BBE--Nature and Instances |
|
Applicability of deeming provision under sections 68 to 69D where nature and sources of income remains unexplained |
|
Disclosure of income subsequently whether can escape from rigour of section 115BBE |
|
Addition justified where deposit not satisfactorily explained |
|
Certain credits, investment or expenditure that commonly come on radar of Department for invoking provision contained under section 115BBE |
|
Applicability of section 115BBE--Certain decisive factors |
25. |
Surrender of Income in Search or Survey and Applicability of Section 115BBE |
|
Background |
|
Detection of undisclosed income one of the objective of survey |
|
Surrender of income during course of survey |
|
No addition can be made without corroborative evidence |
|
Clarification by CBDT regarding confession as to additional income |
|
Applicability of section 115BBE where income voluntarily offered during search or survey |
|
Set-off of business loss against surrendered income |
|
Applicability of section 68 to 69C in respect of income surrendered |
|
Source of income where not explained |
|
Invocation of higher rate of taxation under section 115BBE |
|
Mere surrender where not made sole basis for addition |
|
Surrender where made to buy peace of mind |
|
Concluding position |
26. |
Non-Applicability of Section 115BBE Where Income Classified as Business Income |
|
Non-applicability of section 115BBE in case of surrender of income having business receipt |
|
Surrender on account of excess stock or cash vis-a-vis applicability of section 115BBE |
|
Excess stock found during search taxable as business income and not as unexplained investment if such stock is not separately identifiable |
27. |
Penalty when Leviable under Section 271AAC |
|
Levy of penalty under section 271AAC in respect of income referred to in sections 68 to 69D |
|
Amount of penalty |
|
Overriding provision |
|
Authority empowered to levy penalty under section 271AAC |
|
No penalty where undisclosed income included in return and tax under section 115BBE paid |
|
No penalty to be levied under section 270A in respect of undisclosed income |
|
Applicability of sections 274 and 275 |
|
Total outgo in respect of undisclosed income after giving effect of section 271AAC |
|
Penalty under section 271AAB vis-a-vis penalty under section 271AAC |
|
Part V--Penalty for Bogus Purchase |
28. |
Provisions Regarding Penalty on Bogus Purchases |
|
Introduction |
|
Why section 271AAD |
|
When penalty under section 271AAD leviable |
|
Person--Meaning of |
|
Nature of section 271AAD |
|
Who can levy penalty |
|
Who is assessing officer for the purposes of section 271AAD |
|
Amount of penalty |
|
Quantum of penalty |
|
Penalty on any other person |
|
False entry |
|
Omission of entry |
|
Issues on amount of penalty |
|
Provisions illustrated |
|
Undisclosed income vis-a-vis penalty under section 271AAD |
|
Illustration showing cumulative impact of section 115BBE, 271AAC, 271AAB(1A) and 271AAD |
29. |
Without Prejudice to Any Other Provisions of this Act--Meaning of |
|
Without prejudice to any other provisions of this Act--Scope of expression |
|
Scope of above expression in the context of section 271AAD |
|
Simultaneous penalty under section 270A and section 271AAD--Whether leviable |
30. |
Penalty for False Entry, etc. in Books of Accounts--Retrospectively of Provisions |
|
Date effective from |
|
Can penalty be imposed with retrospective effect |
31. |
Application of Doctrine of Double Jeopardy |
|
Doctrine of double jeopardy |
|
Doctrine of double jeopardy--Whether applies to Income Tax Proceedings |
|
Penalty under other section not barred even if it is levied for bogus purchases under section 271AAD |
|
Penalty and prosecutions both are leviable simultaneously |
32. |
Any Proceeding Under the Act--Scope of |
33. |
Proceedings Against Any Other Person or of Any Other Year--Effect of |
34. |
Scope of Explanation to Section 271AAD |
|
Scope of explanation to section 271AAD which seeks to explain 'false entry' is limited to fake invoice or not |
|
Omission of entry which is relevant for computation of total income of such person to evade tax liability--Scope of |
|
The persons covered in section 271AAD(2) |
|
The persons covered in section 271AAD(2) |
|
Who is assessing officer |
35. |
Maintenance of Books of Accounts--Whether Pre-Condition for Levy of Penalty Under Section 271AAD |
|
Maintenance of books--A pre-condition to levy of penalty under section 271AAD |
|
Books of accounts--Meaning of |
|
Situation 1 : Maintenance of books of accounts required but books not maintained |
|
Situation 2 : Assessee opting for presumptive taxation scheme |
|
Situation 3 : Fake invoices found but not entered in books of accounts. |
|
Situation 4 : Entry operators |
|
Rejection of books |
36. |
Other Issues |
|
Whether levy of penalty under section 271AAD discretionary |
|
Burden of proof |
|
No reasonable cause |
|
Penalty under section 271AAD whether can be waived on ground of reasonable cause |
|
Procedure |
|
Whether section exceeding its stated objective |
|
Appealability of order under section 271AAD |
|
Simultaneous penalty under section 270A and section 271AAD |
|
Important points relating to section 271AAD |
|
Part VI--Other Penalties and Bogus Puchases |
37. |
Penalty under Section 270A for Underreporting and Misreporting of Income |
|
Penalty for underreporting and misreporting of income |
|
Penalty, when can be levied under section 270A |
|
Penalty neither automatic nor mandatory |
|
Authorities empowered to impose penalty under section 270A |
|
Person on whom penalty under section 270A is imposable |
|
Amount of penalty |
|
Order of penalty |
38. |
Underreporting of Income--Statutory Position and Instances |
|
Relevance of underreported income |
|
Instances of underreported income |
|
Circumstances when income would not be considered as underreported |
|
No underreporting of income where explanation regarding thereto is bona fide |
|
Addition on estimate basis not to constitute underreported income where accounts are correct and complete |
|
No underreporting in case of difference between addition or disallowance made by assessee and by assessing officer |
|
No underreporting where addition made in conformity with the arms length price in an international transaction |
|
Underreporting of income vis-a-vis undisclosed income in search cases as referred to in section 271AAB |
|
Identification of different situations vis-a-vis underreporting of income |
|
Where false claim of purchases was made |
|
Where addition was made on the basis of alleged unaccounted sales |
|
Allegation of bogus purchases, however, summons was not issued by assessing officer to suppliers |
|
Penalty imposition where assessee is covered by sections 44AE or 44AF |
|
When supplier in his sworn assessment admitted of having made no sales to assessee |
|
No penalty in case of alleged bogus purchases and summons not issued by AO to suppliers |
|
No penalty where parties to whom purchase made, not traceable |
|
Bogus purchases amount to concealment |
|
Context with section 270A |
|
Necessary ingredients for levying penalty |
39. |
Misreporting of Income--Statutory Position and Instances |
|
Relevance of misreporting of income |
|
Cases of misreporting of income |
|
Misrepresentation or suppression of facts |
|
Failure to record investment in the books of accounts |
|
Expenditure claimed but not substantiated by any evidence |
|
Recording of any false entry in books of account |
|
Failure to record any receipt which is in nature of income |
40. |
Computation of Underreported Income |
|
Method of computation of underreported income |
|
Where return is furnished and income is assessed for the first time |
|
Where no return has been furnished and income is assessed for the first time |
|
Where income is not assessed for the first time |
|
Where underreporting arises out of determination of income under section 115JB/115JC |
|
Where loss is reduced or converted into income as a result of assessment or reassessment |
|
Tabular presentation of determination of underreported income under different situations |
41. |
Computation of Tax Payable on Underreported Income and Penalty Leviable under Section 270A |
|
Quantum of penalty leviable under section 270A |
|
No discretion as to determination of quantum of penalty |
|
Computation of tax payable in respect of underreported income |
|
Illustrations showing computation of tax payable on underreported income and penalty under section 270A |
42. |
Determination of Underreported Income Where Source of Receipt Related to Earlier Years |
|
Penalty under section 270A where underreported income covered by addition made in earlier years |
|
Manner of computing underreported income in case of intangible addition |
|
Illustration clarifying leviability of penalty under section 270A where underreported income is claimed to be covered by additions made in earlier years |
|
Treatment of earlier years additions under section 271(1) |
|
Objectives of Explanation 2 to section 271(1) |
|
Nature of Explanations 2 to section 271(1) |
|
Effect of Explanation 2 |
|
Limitation vis-a-vis application of Explanation 2 |
|
Applicability of Explanation 2 to section 271(1) |
|
Illustration showing applicability of Explanation 2 |
43. |
No Penalty under Section 270A in Case of Bona Fide Explanation |
|
No underreporting of income where assessee offers bona fide explanation and substantiates the same |
|
Conditions to be fulfilled for availing of benefit of the clause (a) of section 270A(6) |
|
Burden of proof on assessee |
|
Provision contained in section 270A(6)(a) vis-a-vis Explanation 1 to section 271(1) |
|
Text of Explanation 1 to section 271(1) |
|
No penalty in case of bona fide explanation |
|
Cases where assessee's explanation held to be bona fide |
|
Ingredients relevant for deciding regarding assessee's bona fides |
|
No penalty where assessee discharged its onus |
|
Penalty to be levied in the absence of bona fide explanation |
|
Penalty imposed without offering opportunity to assessee--Not justified |
|
Benefit of doubt in proceedings to be given to assessee |
|
Disclosure of income in notes to accounts instead of profit and loss account |
|
Passing of penalty order without accepting or rejecting assessees explanation--Effect of |
|
Material collected at the time of assessment cannot be ignored |
|
Finding recorded in quantum proceedings cannot be ignored |
|
Levy of penalty on minor for omission by guardian or representative |
|
Failure to substantiate the explanation offered and also failure to prove that such explanation is bona fide [Part (B) of Explanation 1, corresponding to section 270A(6)(a)] |
|
Burden to prove on assessee as per Explanation 1 also |
|
Applicability of Explanation 1 where debatable entry was reversed by assessee as desired by assessing officer |
|
Assessee where failed to rebut presumption by offering bona fide explanation |
|
Concealment penalty invoking Explanation 1--When not leviable? |
44. |
Determination of Underreported Income on the Basis of Estimate |
|
Addition to income on estimate basis and underreporting of income |
|
Conditions to be fulfilled for avoiding penalty where addition is on estimate basis |
|
Avoidance of penalty where accounts are correct and complete--Practical instances |
|
Burden upon revenue to prove that account are not correct |
|
Accounting method cannot be rejected where correct income was deducible |
|
Books of account cannot be rejected on presumption |
|
Avoiding of penalty where assessee on his own estimated lower amount of addition or disallowance |
|
No penalty leviable where additions are based on estimated profit by applying higher rate |
|
No penalty to be levied where addition or disallowance was merely on the basis of estimate and without any supporting evidence |
|
Revenue has to prove ingredients of concealment (misreporting in current context) |
|
Penalty not leviable for want of positive evidence where there were different estimates by different authorities |
|
No penalty where additions made to income got deleted |
|
Concealment in case of estimation of income after rejecting books of account |
|
No challenge to addition does not amount to admission of concealment |
|
Bona fides of assessee if disapproved, penalty may be leviable |
|
High Court can go behind finding of Tribunal as to concealment in case of estimated addition |
|
No penalty where estimate of assessee was not a result of any gross or wilful negligence |
|
Assessee failed to substantiate genuineness and veracity of its claim of having made purchases but books have not been rejected |
|
Where AO had estimated income/gross profit @ 8% on bogus purchases |
|
When corresponding sale were not doubted |
45. |
Immunity from Penalty Levied under Section 270A |
|
Immunity from penalty and prosecution proceedings |
|
Conditions precedent for grant of immunity from imposition of penalty and prosecution proceedings |
|
No immunity where penalty proceedings initiated in case of misreporting of income |
|
Time limit for filing application for immunity |
|
Immunity to be granted on fulfilment of prescribed conditions |
|
Order accepting or rejecting application for granting immunity |
|
Finality of order |
|
No appeal or revision against assessment or reassessment order where order accepting the application is made |
46. |
Penalty Leviable under Section 271AAB Where Undisclosed Income Found During Search |
|
Penalty in search cases leviable under section 271AAB |
|
Quantum of penalty after amendment by Taxation Laws (Second Amendment) Act, 2016 |
|
Meaning of "specified date" |
|
Meaning of "undisclosed income" for purpose of section 271AAB |
|
No penalty under section 270A or section 271(1)(c) on the amount on which penalty was already levied under section 271AAB |
|
Penalty under section 271AAB not mandatory |
|
Overview of applicability of provision under different situations |
|
Cumulative impact of sections 115BBE, 271AAC and 271AAB(1A) |
|
Illustration |
|
Penalty under section 271AAB leviable on fulfilment of related conditions |
|
No penalty under section 271AAB in absence of search |
|
Determination of undisclosed income on account of household expenditure recorded in seized documents |
|
No undisclosed income once stock recorded in books of account |
|
No undisclosed income on account of personal jewellery |
|
Penalty on basis of excess cash found |
|
Levy of penalty as regards cash advances towards purchase of land |
|
Impact of non-specification of charge in notice |
|
Penalty merely on basis of Statement recorded under section 132(4) |
|
Undisclosed investment found during search where no column in return to disclose said investment |
|
No penalty in absence of any material |
|
Disallowance of claim of deduction |
|
Applicability of clause (c) of Explanation to section 271AAB |
|
Initiation of penalty proceedings against a dead person not valid |
|
Stay on demand raised on unexplained income |
|
Part VII--Penalty for Concealment and Bogus Purchases [For Assessment Year Prior to Assessment Year 2017-18] |
47. |
Levy of Penalty under Section 271 for Concealment of Income and for Furnishing Inaccurate Particulars of Income [For Period Upto Assessment Year 2016-17] |
|
Applicability and relevance of section 271 |
|
Disallowance of claim vis-a-vis penalty under section 271(1) |
|
Penalty when leviable under section 271 |
|
Penalty under section 271 can be levied for two distinct offences |
|
'Has concealed particulars of income' and 'has furnished inaccurate particulars of income'--Connotation of |
|
Concealment and furnishing of inaccurate particulars of income--Elaboration and distinction |
|
Provisions under which penalty imposable should be clearly stated |
|
Principles vis-a-vis impostion of concealment penalty |
|
Requirement regarding satisfaction of assessing officer |
|
Bogus purchases disallowed but sales not doubted--Whether concealment penalty leviable |
|
Deletion of addition towards bogus purchases in quantum appeal |
|
Estimation of higher rate of profits on purchases but no active concealment |
|
Assessee failed to substantiate genuineness and veracity of its claim of having made purchases but books have not been rejected |
|
Disallowance on account of bogus purchases and addition made on estimate basis |
|
Where CIT(A) sustained addition of 12.5% made by AO |
|
No penalty leviable where addition made on basis of estimation |
|
No clinching material to disprove the authenticity of the purchases |
|
Where AO had estimated income/gross profit @ 8% on bogus purchases |
|
Where addition was made on estimate basis but assessee produced all documents except goods transportation proof |
|
AO estimated profit element from non-genuine purchases at 12.5% |
|
Leviability on penalty as regards addition on ad hoc basis |
|
No satisfaction as to concealment recorded in the order of assessment |
|
Where assessee had only filed the copy of the ledger of the purchases from one-party but had failed to file the copies of the bill/invoices for the freight charges, octroi details of the vehicles used in the transportation of the goods--Penalty leviable |
|
Where AO assumed jurisdiction wrongly |
|
When corresponding sale were not doubted |
|
CIT(A) sustained the addition at 12.5% of the bogus |
48. |
Addition or Disallowances Vis-a-Vis Penalty under Section 271 or under Section 270A |
|
Addition or disallowance constitutes underreported income under section 270A |
|
No underreporting of income in certain cases |
|
Higher penalty where addition or disallowance represents misreporting of income |
|
Safeguards provided against levy of double jeopardy due to addition or disallowance |
|
Mere disallowance of claim for expenditure or disallowance of deduction--Does not attract penal provisions |
|
Disallowance of claim vis-a-vis levy of penalty under section 270A |
49. |
Burden of Proof |
|
Position under section 271(1) vis-a-vis section 270A |
|
History of burden to prove under section 271 |
|
Shifting of burden of proof on assessee [Position from 1-4-1964] |
|
Revenue liable to prove even after amendment by Finance Act, 1964 |
|
Burden of proof lies on assessee under Explanation 1 to section 271 |
|
Supreme Court's view in Dilip N. Shroff's case and in T. Ashok Pai's case |
|
Decision in Dilip N Shroff's case was required to be reconsidered by Larger Bench in view of mandatory penalty under section 11AC of Central Excise Act --Observations in Dharmendra Textile's case |
|
Nature of burden of proof on assessee |
|
Onus of discharge of burden of proof, when lies on assessee |
|
Any kind of evidence can be relied on in discharging burden of proof |
|
No penalty can be levied where assessee furnishes relevant details |
|
Explanation raises rebuttable presumption |
|
Burden shifts again to revenue where Explanation stands rebutted |
50. |
Explanations to Section 271(1) |
|
Failure to offer explanation or explanation found to be false or failure to substantiate and to prove that such explanation is bona fide [Explanation 1] |
|
Concealment in case of intangible addition [Explanation 2] |
|
Failure to furnish return of income for assessment year 1989-90 or any year subsequent thereto without reasonable cause [Explanation 3] |
|
Amount of tax sought to be evaded--Meaning of [Explanation 4] |
|
Concealment in case of assets found during search initiated before 1-6-2007 [Explanation 5] |
|
Concealment in case of assets found during search initiated on or after 1-6-2007 [Explanation 5A] |
|
Deemed concealment in case of international transaction [Explanation 7] |
|
Part VIII--Other Issues Relevant to Penalty |
51. |
Possibilities of Reducing or Waiving Penalty Under Section 270A or Section 271(1)(iii) in Certain Cases |
|
Waiver or reduction of penalty |
|
Principal Commissioner or Commissioner empowered to reduce or waive penalty |
|
When would assessee be deemed to have made full and true disclosure |
|
Approval of Principal Chief Commissioner or Chief Commissioner or Principal Director General or Director General |
|
Reduction or waiver under section 273A(1) is possible only once in life of a person |
|
Waiver or reduction of penalty by Principal Commissioner or Commissioner under specific circumstances [Section 273A(4)] |
|
Time limit for disposing of application under section 273A |
|
Order passed under section 273A shall be final [Section 273A(5)] |
|
Conditions for reduction or waiver of penalty |
|
Mere fulfilment of conditions precedent does not entitle for waiver or reduction of penalty |
|
Waiver can be in respect of more than one assessment by a common order |
|
Power of suo motu waiver |
|
Waiver or reduction to be in cases where penalty is imposable |
|
No limitation for making application under section 273A |
|
For making application, imposition of penalty is not necessary |
|
Full and not substantial compliance required |
|
Filing of appeal against penalty vis-a-vis application under section 273A |
|
Refusal to grant waiver of penalty by Commissioner |
|
Admission of petition by Settlement Commission |
|
Writ court's jurisdiction |
|
Writ against dismissal of first waiver application where fresh application pending before Commissioner |
|
No estoppel against penalty |
|
Rejection of application without giving reasons |
|
Assessee enjoying benefits of settlement |
|
Assessee having availed of Amnesty Scheme |
|
Delayed filing of return due to books of account seized by CBI |
|
Benefit of section 273A not available where part of the concealed income detected prior to the disclosure |
|
Discretion of CIT not fettered by any advice from any other authority, once condition stipulated in section 273A is satisfied |
|
Cases in which rejection of application for reduction or waiver of penalty under section 273A held justified |
|
Cases in which application for reduction or waiver of penalty under section 273A held not justified |
|
Commissioner is not required to exercise his powers either wholly in favour of assessee or wholly against him |
|
Duty of CIT while exercising power under section 273A |
|
Specimen of application for waiver of penalty under section 273A |
52. |
Disclosure in Good Faith and Voluntarily and Co-operation by Assessee |
|
Meaning of the word 'voluntarily' in section 273A |
|
Disclosure in good faith and voluntarily--Some judicial pronouncements |
|
--Disclosure in return filed voluntarily, even if not accepted, is a valid disclosure |
|
--Disclosure by assessee held to be voluntarily and in good faith |
|
--Revised return cannot be treated as voluntary where enquiry initiated |
|
--Disclosure of income not made before issue of notices under section 148 |
|
--Facts found concurrently |
|
--Earning of taxable income by assessee is not sufficient for inferring an involuntary disclosure |
|
--Where revised return accepted by authority and no additions made |
|
--Disclosure after detection |
|
--Disclosure after search |
|
Filing of voluntary return not a condition precedent for exercise of discretion by Commissioner |
|
Commissioner's jurisdiction not barred merely because assessee did not file return under section 139 within time |
|
Refusal by Commissioner to exercise his power |
|
Disclosure for the purposes of section 273A can be even otherwise than in a valid return |
|
Co-operation by assessee |
53. |
Exercise of Jurisdiction by Principal Commissioner or Commissioner Under Section 273A |
|
Controversies generally arising vis-a-vis jurisdiction of Principal Commissioner or Commissioner under section 273A |
|
Nature of power of Principal Commissioner or Commissioner |
|
Opportunity of being heard by Principal Commissioner or Commissioner |
|
Application of mind by Principal Commissioner or Commissioner |
|
Granting of relief under section 273A not mandatory even where conditions technically satisfied |
|
Jurisdiction of Commissioner |
|
Discretion to be exercised judiciously |
|
Commissioner putting conditions for waiver--Fulfilment of conditions whether attracts promissory estoppel |
|
Order of Commissioner must be a speaking order |
|
Form of order under section 273A |
|
Rectification of order passed under section 273A |
54. |
Power of Principal Commissioner or Commissioner under Section 273A(4) for Waiver or Reduction of Penalty |
|
Waiver or reduction of penalty under section 273A(4) |
|
Section 273A(1) vis-a-vis section 273A(4) |
|
Genuine hardship and satisfaction of Commissioner |
|
Wide discretion to waive penalty |
|
Interference of High Court |
|
Power exercisable despite assessee pursuing appeal remedy |
|
Recording of reasons--Necessity of |
55. |
Procedure Regarding Levy of Penalty |
|
Procedure for levy of penalty [Section 274] |
|
Provisions of section 274 purely procedural |
|
Proceedings should be disposed of by officer having jurisdiction |
|
Reasonable opportunity of being heard |
|
Sufficiency of opportunity of being heard as given--Question of law or fact |
|
Reliance, in penalty proceedings, on evidence collected in assessment proceedings--Opportunity to assessee, a condition precedent |
|
Show-cause notice necessary for validity of penalty |
|
Form of notice to show cause |
|
Issuance of two parallel notices for the same assessment year |
|
No provision for drawing up charge sheet, only notice and opportunity of being heard necessary |
|
Notice should indicate particular contravention |
|
Opportunity to put evidence in defence |
|
Notice provides opportunity to send a written representation |
|
Consequences of defective penalty notice |
|
Nexus between ground for initiation of proceedings and that for actual imposition, is essential |
|
Penalty proceedings, dropped earlier by revenue, cannot be initiated again on the same facts |
|
Jurisdiction of succeeding assessing officer |
|
Consequences of not providing a reasonable opportunity |
|
Impact of non-compliance of requirements of section 274(2)(b) |
|
Providing mechanism for faceless penalty |
|
Notification of scheme |
56. |
Limitation Period for Imposition of Penalty |
|
Scheme of section 275(1) |
|
--Where relevant assessment order or other order is subject matter of appeal to CIT(A) or to Appellate Tribunal [Section 275(1)(a)] |
|
--Where relevant assessment or other order is subject matter of an appeal to CIT(A) and he passes order on or after 1-6-2003 disposing of such appeal [Proviso to section 275(1)(a)] |
|
--Where relevant assessment or other order is subject matter of revision under section 263 or section 264 [Section 275(1)(b)] |
|
--Limitation in any other case [Section 275(1)(c)] |
|
Penalty can be imposed/enhanced/reduced/cancelled on the basis of appellate/ revision orders [Section 275(1A)] |
|
Exclusion of periods for computing limitation |
|
Amendment of section 275 with effect from 1-4-1989 not to apply to proceedings initiated on or before 31-3-1989 |
|
Provisions of section 275 are mandatory |
|
Provisions of section 275 are procedural and retrospective |
|
Period of limitation, which date to start from |
|
Law, as on date of imposition of penalty, applicable |
|
Bar of limitation applies only to order passed by primary authorities |
|
Remand orders not hit by bar of limitation |
|
Provisions of section 275 not to be construed in a way so as to interfere with the hierarchical scheme for correction of penalty orders |
|
Applicability of limitation period in case of quantum appeal |
|
Proceeding in the course of which action for imposition of penalty has been initiated or completed |
|
Provisions of section 275 apply only to the first order of penalty |
|
Penalty proceeding to be kept pending until final outcome of appeal |
|
Rule of procedure are the rules in force |
|
Notice issued after expiry of limitation period |
|
Penalty order passed beyond six months from initiation of penalty proceedings--Not correct |
|
Question whether amended section 275 is applicable, is question of law or fact |
|
Original assessment remanded by appellate authority -- Effect of |
|
Applicability of section 268 while computing limitation period |
|
Part IX--Prosecution Aspects |
57. |
Wilful Attempt to Evade Tax, Etc. |
|
Prosecution where assessee underreports income |
|
Immunity from prosecution under section 270AA |
|
Wilful attempt to evade payment of any tax, etc., is also liable to prosecution |
|
What is included in wilful attempt to evade tax |
|
No prosecution under certain sections except with the previous sanction of the Commissioner, etc. |
|
Ingredients of the offence for prosecution under section 276C |
|
What if second offence is committed under section 276C(1) |
|
No prosecution under this section where penalty is reduced or waived by order under section 273A |
|
Offence under this section is non-cognizable |
|
Mens rea essential |
|
Meaning of attempt to evade tax |
|
Prosecution where no intentional suppression of income by assessee |
|
Deliberate misstatements with a view to evading tax |
|
Net income assessed being loss |
|
Offence independent of assessment order |
|
No prosecution when penalty dropped |
|
No show-cause notice necessary |
|
Successor officer competent to represent complaint |
|
Prosecution not to be quashed due to delay in launching |
|
No offence committed under section 276C where there was time available to file return |
|
Stay of penalty proceedings due to appellate proceedings |
|
Exemption from personal appearance |
|
Prosecution of partnership firm |
|
Company cannot be subjected to bodily punishment |
|
Duty of Criminal Court |
|
Evasion of tax by producing false medical certificate |
|
False statement in respect of price of land in Form No. 37G |
|
Prosecution cases in which offences not proved |
|
Where income concealed is less than Rs. 25,000--No prosecution be launched in view of CBDT Circular |
|
Compounding of offences--Hearing opportunity to applicants by CBDT |
|
Maintainability of fresh complaint for same offence |
|
Tribunal's finding whether binding or criminal Court ? |
|
Duty of criminal court to give due regard to proceedings under the Act |
|
Launching of prosecution |
|
--Expression used in section 276C clearly states that assessment need not be completed before launching prosecution |
|
--Attempt to evade tax is sufficient for action under section 276C |
|
--Deduction claimed when actually donation was not passed to authorised institutions--Is prima facie case for prosecution |
|
--Where claim for exemption wrongly made |
|
--Presumption laid down under section 132(4A) |
|
Pendency of income-tax proceeding not a bar to institution of criminal proceedings |
|
Pending of reassessment proceedings cannot act as bar to finalisation of trial |
|
Basis of complaint nullified by the superior authority |
|
Effect of waiver of penalty under section 273A |
|
Where Settlement Commission granted immunity from criminal prosecution |
|
Pendency of application before Settlement Commission |
|
Power of High Court to interfere with order of acquittal |
|
Establishment of offence |
|
Later conviction possible |
|
Maintainability of complaint by successor officer |
|
Where Tribunal had set aside the penalty |
|
Department accepted that income had not been concealed |
|
Department need not have launched prosecution hurriedly |
|
Maintainability of prosecution--Cancellation of penalty under section 271(1)(c) by High Court |
|
Fine reduced |
|
Tribunal partly allowed appeal of assessee regarding addition |
|
Penalty under section 271(1) deleted by Tribunal--Revenue did not file appeal |
|
Return signed by partner of firm not proved by the High Court and thus, acquitted partner |
|
Petition for discharge under section 245D(2) Cr PC vis-a-vis cancellation of penalty under section 271(1)(c) |
|
No conscious concealment |
|
Immunity from prosecution and penalty by Settlement Commission--Effect of |
|
Acquittal of accused for absence of complainant |
|
Revenue found assessee guilty |
|
Charge of concealment of income being extinguished |
|
Additions based on diary found in search subsequently deleted |
|
Assessment order being basis of criminal prosecution pending before the Supreme Court |
|
Prosecution imposed only if intention is wilful |
|
Prosecution--Effect of assessment under section 153A |
|
No prosecution where offences not proved |
|
--Prosecution to prove case beyond reasonable doubt |
|
--Mere addition in income does not automatically attract prosecution |
|
--Absence of assessment, demand or recovery proceedings would invalidate prosecution proceedings |
|
--Evidence on record not proving charge |
|
--Where ingredients of offence not established beyond reasonable doubt |
|
--Prosecution failing to prove case |
|
No need to afford an opportunity of being heard before according sanction for launching prosecution |
|
Allegation against petitioner is of evasion of tax |
58. |
Prosecution for False Statement in Verification, Etc. |
|
Provisions of section 277 |
|
Ingredients of offence for punishment under section 277 |
|
What if second offence is committed under section 276B |
|
No prosecution where penalty is reduced or waived by order under section 273A |
|
Offence under this section is non-cognizable |
|
Pendency of penalty proceedings |
|
--Penalty cancelled by appellate authority |
|
--When penalty proceedings cancelled by Tribunal |
|
--Penalty under section 271(1)(c) and assessment set aside in appeal |
|
--Initiation of penalty proceedings is not a condition precedent to institution of complaint under section 277 |
|
--Simultaneous application of penalty and prosecution provisions possible |
|
--No penalty under section 271(1)(c) in case assessee sustains loss |
|
--Quashing of complaint when penalty for concealment of income set aside by CIT(A) |
|
--Maintainability of prosecution when appeal against cancellation of penalty by CIT(A) pending |
|
If false statement has no effect on assessment, person cannot be prosecuted for it |
|
Person making return with verification under his signature will be deemed to be liable |
|
Mens rea an essential ingredient of offence |
|
'Evasion of tax' is essential for awarding punishment |
|
Prosecution against partner of firm |
|
Prosecution in case of companies for offences under section 277 |
|
Firm is liable to be convicted for acts of partners, in same way as companies |
|
Sufficiency of addition made on estimate basis to prove false statement to evade tax on the part of assessee |
|
Order according sanction not filed along with complaint |
|
Issuance of show cause notice not necessary |
|
Opportunity of being heard |
|
Power of Court |
|
Income Tax Officer and Commissioner exempted from personal appearance |
|
Effect of pardon granted under section 306 Cr. P.C. on prosecution |
|
Period of stay |
|
Allegedly furnishing false TDS certificate and obtaining refund |
|
Refund certificate in fictitious names |
|
Allegedly furnishing of a false declaration in return of income |
59. |
Prosecution for Falsification of Books of Account or Document, Etc. [Section 277A] |
|
Provisions explained |
|
Tax evasion not to be proved |
|
Applicability of section 277A |
|
No prosecution under this section except with the previous sanction of the Commissioner, etc. |
|
Makes or causes to be made--Scope of |
|
'Wilful' imports concept of 'mens rea' |
|
Mens rea is essential |
|
There must be intention to defraud revenue |
|
Consequences of section 277A |
60. |
Prosecution for Abetment of False Return, Etc. |
|
Abetting or inducing to furnish false statement, etc., to bring prosecution |
|
Punishment for the offence under section 278 |
|
Ingredients of the offence for prosecution under section 278 |
|
What if second offence is committed under section 278 |
|
Offence under this section is non-cognizable |
|
For prosecution under section 278 prosecution under section 276C or section 277 not necessary |
|
Preparation of returns by Chartered Accountant not abetment |
|
Assessment need not be completed before launching prosecution |
|
Request for discharge of partners accused of submitting false return and manipulation of accounts |
|
Sales allegedly made outside books of accounts--Penalty for concealment deleted by Commissioner (Appeals) affirmed by the Tribunal |
|
Penalty under section 271(1)(c) set aside by appellate authority |
|
Mere fact that husbands of the partners had attended proceedings, would not mean that they had abetted offence |
|
Whether offence had been committed is a matter of evidence to be decided at trial |
|
Compounding of offences during pendency of appeal |
|
Liability of directors of company in charge of its affairs |
61. |
Punishment for Second & Subsequent Offences under Sections 276B, 276C(1), 276CC, 277 & 278 |
|
Provisions of section 278A |
|
Scope of section 278A |
62. |
Punishment Not to be Imposed in Certain Cases under Sections 276A, 276AB and 276B |
|
Scope of section 278AA |
|
Ingredients of offence for punishment under section 278AA |
|
Section 278AA is nothing else but a proviso to section 276B |
|
Accused not required to prove before criminal court by leading independent evidence in relation to reasonable cause for his failure |
|
Safeguard against arbitrary action of authorities |
|
No writ maintainable against sanction for prosecution |
63. |
Immunity from Prosecution |
|
Power of Principal Commissioner or Commissioner to grant immunity from prosecution |
|
Scheme for granting immunity |
64. |
Offences by Companies, Firms, AOPs, BOIs, Etc. |
|
Scope of section 278B |
|
Company and its chiefs are liable for prosecution [Section 278B(1)] |
|
When company's directors, etc., can escape prosecution [Proviso to section 278B(1)] |
|
Directors, etc., when liable for prosecution [Section 278B(2)] |
|
Position when prescribed punishment is imprisonment and fine both [Section 278B(3)] |
|
Meaning of 'person in charge' |
|
--Determination of 'principal officer' not necessary |
|
--Principal officer and in charge of affairs of company, whether can be proceeded against |
|
--Issue of notice to partners for treating them as principal officer is necessary |
|
--Whether particular person was in charge of conduct of company is question of fact |
|
--Where no allegation in complaint that accused was in charge of business |
|
--Complaint bound to provide indication as to in what manner particular partner was in charge of business |
|
--Partner not being responsible for business of firm, is not liable |
|
--Provisions of section 278B override provisions of section 41A of State Financial Corporation Act |
|
Position in case of a firm/AOP/BOI and its partners/members |
|
'Person' under section 2(31) read with section 278B includes 'firm' |
|
Ingredients of offence for prosecution under section 278B |
|
Determination of "principal officer" not necessary |
|
Every person who was in charge of the company at the relevant time liable to be prosecuted |
|
Partner who is not responsible for business of firm is not liable |
|
Burden of proof on revenue that person concerned was incharge of the affairs of the firm |
|
Prosecution of lady partner who did not participate in affairs of the firm --Not permissible |
|
Prosecution of directors of company for offence under section 278B |
|
Partner who is in overall control of day to day business of firm is liable |
|
Benefit of proviso to section 278B(1) |
65. |
Offences by Hindu Undivided Family |
|
Liability of HUF and Karta--When offence is committed by HUF |
|
Member of HUF may also be prosecuted |
|
Liability for the offence for prosecution under section 278C--On whom |
|
Karta liable for offence by HUF |
66. |
Recent Guidelines Regarding Compounding of Offences Under Income Tax Act, 1961 |
|
Compounding provision |
|
Applicability of guidelines |
|
Compounding is not a matter of right |
|
Applicability of these Guidelines to prosecutions under IPC |
|
Classification of Offences |
|
Eligibility conditions for compounding |
|
Offences not to be compounded |
|
Offences normally not to be compounded |
|
Authority Competent to Compound an Offence |
|
Compounding procedure |
|
Compounding Charges |
|
Compounding fee |
|
Co-accused and Abettor |
|
Offences for which no compounding fee has been prescribed |
|
Book 2--Fake Invoices Under GST |
|
Part I--Fake Invoices Under GST |
67. |
Fake Invoice--Objective and Consequences |
|
Introduction |
|
Input tax credit laundering |
|
Modus operanding in making fake invoices |
|
Meaning of fake invoice |
|
Role of fake invoices in GST regime |
|
Potential motives for using fake invoices |
|
Salient features of GST frauds involving fake inovices |
|
Implications of fake invoices on economy |
|
Measures to keep check on issuance of fake invoices |
|
Consequences of issuance or acceptance of fake invoices |
|
Penal provisions vis--vis fake invoices |
|
Prosecution proceeding vis--vis fake invoices |
|
APPENDIX |
|
Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) for Tackling Fake Invoice Cases |
68. |
Detecting and Tackling Fake Invoice Frauds |
|
Measures to keep check on issuance of fake invoices |
|
Suggested strategy to tackle "fake inovice" frauds in GST |
|
Standard Operating Procedure for detecting and tackling "Fake invoice" fraud in GST |
|
Consequences of issuance or acceptance of fake invoices |
|
Action after detection of fraud invoice cases |
|
Penal provisions vis--vis fake invoices |
|
Prosecution proceeding vis--vis fake invoices |
|
Part II--Preventive Measures Under GST Vis-a-Vis Fake Invoices |
69. |
Blocking of Input Tax Credit Under Rule 86A |
|
Power of Commissioner to block input tax credit |
|
SOP for blocking/unblocking of Input Tax Credit |
|
Guidelines for invoking disallowing debit of electronic credit ledger |
|
Satisfaction to be based on credible material or information |
|
Blocking of negative ITC balance is not sustainable |
|
Order under rule 86A would create lien upto limit specified in the order |
|
Entire credit cannot be blocked |
|
Blocking of ITC ledger due to non-filing of GSTR-3B by its vendor |
|
Assessee cannot be permitted to avail ITC pending enquiry |
|
Taxpayer must file objection |
|
Blocking of ITC would cease after expiry of one year |
|
ITC of director cannot be blocked for effective recovery of dues of a company |
|
APPENDIX |
|
Blocking of Credit Under Rule 86A of SGST Rules, 2017--Guidelines Issued--Reg. |
|
Guidelines for Disallowing Debit of Electronic Credit Ledger under Rule 86A of the UPGST Rules, 2017 |
70. |
Audits under GST |
|
Statutory provisions dealing with audit of accounts |
|
Audit--Defined |
|
I. DEPARTMENTAL AUDIT |
|
Who can conduct audit of business transactions |
|
Periodicity of audit |
|
Place, where audit may be conducted |
|
Fifteen working days advance notice |
|
Time period of completion of audit |
|
Commencement of audit--Meaning of |
|
Duties of registered person |
|
Scope of audit |
|
Intimation of findings and discrepancies to registered person |
|
Initiation of action for recovery of tax not paid, short-paid, etc. |
|
II. SPECIAL AUDIT |
|
Officer empowered to give direction for special audit |
|
Cases, where direction for special audit can be given |
|
Approval of Commissioner is necessary |
|
Persons authorised to conduct special audit |
|
Audit report to be furnished within 90 days |
|
Informing finding of special audit to registered person |
|
Special audit would be in addition to any other audit |
|
Opportunity of being heard to registered person |
|
Access to business premises |
|
Taxable person is required to provide necessary documents |
|
Audit fee and incidental expenses to be paid by Commissioner |
|
Action under section 73 or section 74 |
71. |
Search, Seizure and Arrest |
|
Statutory provisions governing inspection, search and seizure |
|
Power to inspect place of business |
|
Deputy Assistant Commissioner is not empowered to pass order under section 67(2) |
|
Reasons should be recorded before issuing search warrant |
|
Contents of a Search Warrant |
|
Search without a warrant would be illegal |
|
Inspection in movement |
|
Seizure and seizure of goods, documents, books or things |
|
Power of High Court to quash search proceedings |
|
Where it is not practicable to seize goods |
|
Entrusting ownership of goods to owner or custodian of goods |
|
Retention of goods, documents, etc., and return thereof |
|
Power to seal or break open door, Almirah, box, etc. |
|
Right to make copies of documents seized or take extracts |
|
Release of seized goods on provisional basis |
|
Goods to be returned, if no notice is issued within sixty days |
|
Disposal of goods of perishable or hazardous nature after their seizure |
|
Preparing inventory of goods |
|
Applicability of provisions of Code of Criminal Procedure |
|
Seizure of accounts, registers or documents |
|
Purchase of goods or services by any officer authorised by Commissioner and return thereof |
|
Principles to be observed during search operations |
|
Person in charge of a conveyance is required to carry prescribed documents |
|
Details are required to be validated |
|
Person in charge of vehicle is required to produce documents |
|
Exclusivity of powers of Central Authorities as well as State Authorities |
72. |
Summon under GST |
|
Need of summon |
|
Who can summon and who can be summoned? |
|
Purpose to summon |
|
Department cannot expand scope of enquiry by issuing summon |
|
Consequences of non-appearance to summons |
|
Every inquiry to be a judicial proceeding |
|
Guidelines for issue of summons |
|
Precautions to be observed while issuing summons |
|
Who shall have power to access to business premises |
|
Duty of person-in-charge of premises |
|
Officers required to assist proper officers |
|
Determination of tax is not necessary for issuing summon |
|
Parellel enquiry proceeding by officers of different jurisdiction |
|
Part III--Penal Provisions Relating to Fake Invoices |
73. |
Detention and Seizure of Goods and Conveyances |
|
Documents and devices to be carried by a person-in-charge of a conveyance |
|
--Documents and devices to be carried |
|
--In case of issuance of e-invoice |
|
--Transporters of goods to obtain Radio Frequency Indentification Device |
|
--Documents to be carried in lieu of e-way bill |
|
Detention, seizure and release of goods and conveyances in transit |
|
--Detention or seizure of goods |
|
--Issuance of notice |
|
--Grant of opportunity of being heard |
|
--Conclusion of proceedings on payment of amount |
|
--Consequences of failure to pay penalty within 15 days |
|
Release of goods |
|
--Provisions applicable upto 31-7-2021 |
|
--Provision applicable from 1-8-2021 |
|
--Release of goods upon furnishing of security or bond |
|
--Demand of both Security and Bank Guarantee for release of goods not valid |
|
--Meaning of owner of goods |
|
--Goods being perishable in nature |
|
Procedure for detention, seizure and release or confiscation of goods and conveyances |
|
No physical verification to be carried out more than once |
|
Goods and/or conveyances in respect of which there is no violation, not to be detained |
|
No penalty imposable for minor spelling or clerical mistakes |
|
Transportation of goods with expired e-way bill--Detention of goods and vehicles |
|
Carrying gold without delivery challan--Confiscation of |
|
Validity of e-way bill expired due to detention of vehicle by transport department |
|
Difference in value in e-way bill and original delivery challan |
|
Value quoted in invoice being lower than maximum retail price of goods |
|
Detention of goods on ground of "wrong Destination"--Validity |
|
Bona fide dispute with regard to classification of goods |
|
Detention order without appreciating documents relating to vehicle |
|
Confiscation of goods or conveyances and levy of penalty |
|
Intention to evade tax must exist to invoke provisions of section 130 |
|
Wrongful claim of input tax credit is not reason to invoke section 130 |
|
Consignment accompanied with invoice and e-way bill |
|
No confication can be ordered where statutory appeal is pending |
|
No show cause notice can be issued on mere suspicion |
|
Undervaluation of goods cannot be a ground for seizure of goods in transit |
|
Change of route is no ground to invoke provisions of section 130 |
|
Scope of powers of authorities under sections 129 and 130 |
|
Confiscation of goods on mere suspicion not sustainable |
|
Notice sent in Form GST MOV-10 not complying with requirement of law |
|
Option to pay fine in lieu of confiscation |
|
Payment of tax, penalty and charges in respect of goods or conveyance |
|
Opportunity of being heard |
|
Title of goods would vest in Government |
|
Taking and holding of possession of things confiscated |
|
Disposal of goods |
|
Confiscation or penalty would not interfere with other punishments |
74. |
Demands of Tax and Adjudication Proceedings |
|
Statutory provisions dealing with demand and recovery of tax |
|
Comparative chart showing scheme of provisions under sections 73 and 74 |
|
I. DEMAND AND RECOVERY OF TAX UNDER SECTION 73 |
|
Cases when provisions of section 73 be invoked |
|
Service of show cause notice |
|
Mode of service of notice, order, etc. |
|
Demand of tax on the basis of vague show cause notice--Validity |
|
Show cause notice not specifying grounds for proceeding against taxpayer |
|
Time limit for service of show cause notice |
|
Issuance of statement for subsequent period on the same ground |
|
Second show cause notice cannot be issued for same period |
|
Payment of tax before issue of show cause notice--Effect of |
|
Issuance of show cause notice for recovery of amount falling short |
|
No penalty imposable where tax is paid within 30 days of issuance of show cause notice |
|
Payment of tax would not absolve from prosecution proceeding |
|
Determination of tax, interest and penalty |
|
Time limit for issuing order under section 73(9) |
|
Imposition penalty upon failure to pay self-assessed tax |
|
Conclusion of proceeding in respect of co-noticee |
|
II. DEMAND AND RECOVERY OF TAX UNDER SECTION 74 |
|
When can provisions of section 74 be invoked? |
|
Suppression--Meaning of |
|
Issuance of show cause notice |
|
Time limit for issuance of notice |
|
Issuance of statement for subsequent period on the same ground |
|
Corrigendum to show cause notice--Validity |
|
Allegation of fraud or wilful-misstatement or suppression of facts to be set out in show cause notice |
|
Department being aware of activity of assessee--Allegation of fraud, wilful mis-statement is not sustainable |
|
No mala fide intention on part of assessee--Extended period cannot be invoked |
|
Payment of tax and interest before issue of show cause notice--Effect of |
|
Issuance of show cause notice for recovery of amount falling short |
|
Payment of tax, interest and 25% of penalty within 30 days of issuance of show cause notice--Consequences of |
|
Payment of tax would not absolve from prosecution proceeding |
|
Determination of tax, interest and penalty |
|
Time limit for making order under sub-section (10) of section 74 |
|
Tax, interest and 50% of penalty paid within 30 days of issuance of adjudication order--Consequences of |
|
Conclusion of proceeding in respect of co-noticee |
|
III. GENERAL PROVISIONS RELATING TO DETERMINATION OF TAX |
|
Effect of stay of service of notice or issuance of order--Effect of |
|
Demand of tax for normal limitation period would be sustainable where demand for extended period is quashed |
|
Order required to be issued in pursuance of direction of Tribunal |
|
Opportunity of personal hearing |
|
Adjournment of hearing |
|
Relevant facts and basis of decision to be set out in order |
|
Adjudication order cannot travel beyond show-cause notice |
|
Order passed before the date of furnishing reply to show cause notice |
|
Demand raised for different years by issuing show cause notice for one year |
|
Proceeding initiated without issuance of Form GST ASMT-10--Validity of |
|
Modification of interest and penalty consequent to modification of demand |
|
Deemed conclusion of adjudication proceeding after specified period |
|
Exclusion of certain period for passing adjudication order |
|
Self-assessed tax is liable to be recovered under section 79 |
|
No penalty imposable under other provisions where penalty is imposed under section 73 or 74 |
|
Tax to be deposited within 90 days |
|
Generation and quoting of DIN |
75. |
Penal Provisions vis-a-vis Fake Invoices |
|
Penalties vis-a-vis fake invoices |
|
Penalty under section 73(9) |
|
Penalty under section 73(9) is not imposable if tax is paid before or within 30 days of issuance of show cause notice |
|
Penalty for failure to pay self-assessed tax or any amount collected as tax |
|
No penalty is imposable under section 73(11) where return has been filed |
|
Penalty under section 74 |
|
--Statutory provisions |
|
--Reduction of penalty to 15% where tax is paid before issuance of show cause notice |
|
--Reduction of penalty to 25% where tax is paid within 30 days of issuance of show cause notice |
|
--Reduction of penalty to 50% where tax is paid within 30 days of communication of order |
|
Supply of goods or services without issue of invoice or bill |
|
Issuance of invoice or bill without supply of goods or services |
|
Taking or utilizing input tax credit without actual receipt of goods or services |
|
Obtaining refund fraudulently |
|
Taking or distributing input tax credit wrongly |
|
Falsifying or substituting fake accounts or documents |
|
Transporting taxable goods without cover of prescribed documents |
|
Failure to keep, maintain or retain books of account |
|
Supplying, transporting or storing any goods liable for confiscation |
|
Issuing any invoice or document by using other person registration number |
|
Tempering or destroying any material evidence or documents |
|
Supplying any goods or services without paying tax |
|
Availing or utilizing input tax credit wrongly |
|
Aiding or abeting any offence |
|
Receiving or supplying services in contravention of Act or Rules |
|
Failure to issue or account for an inovice |
|
General penalty |
|
Penalty for transport of goods in violation of provisions of the Act or Rules |
76. |
Recovery of Tax, Interest and Penalty |
|
Amount collected as CGST is required to be deposited to Government |
|
Issue of show cause notice requiring payment of tax and penalty |
|
Determination of amount due to be paid |
|
Interest is also payable |
|
Opportunity of hearing to be granted upon request |
|
Time limit for passing order |
|
Period of stay to be excluded from limitation period |
|
Relevant facts and basis of decision to be set out in order |
|
Amount paid would be adjusted against tax payable in respect of related supply |
|
Refund of amount paid |
|
Tax wrongfully collected and paid to Central Government or State Government shall be refunded |
|
Integrated tax wrongly paid on intra-State supply would be adjusted against tax liability without payment of interest |
|
Initiation of recovery proceedings |
|
Recovery of tax |
|
Deduction from amount payable to assessee |
|
Sale of goods belonging to taxable person |
|
Recovery by a garnishee order (i.e. recovery from a third party) |
|
--Issue of notice [Section 79(1)(c)(i)] |
|
--Third party is bound to make payment [Section 79(1)(c)(ii)] |
|
--Failure to make payment--Consequences of [Section 79(1)(c)(iii)] |
|
--Amendment or revocation of notice [Section 79(1)(c)(iv)] |
|
--Tax would be deemed to be paid by defaulting person [Section 79(1) (c)(v)] |
|
--Person to whom notice is issued would be personally liable |
|
--Third party may prove otherwise--Consequences of |
|
--Important case law |
|
Distraining and detaining movable or immovable property belonging to assessee |
|
Recovery of amount as arrears of land revenue |
|
Recovery of amount as fine under Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 |
|
Recovery of amount in the manner laid down in any bond or instrument |
|
Power of proper officer of State tax or Union territory to recover amount as arrears of State tax or Union territory tax |
|
Recovery through execution of a decree, etc. |
|
Recovery by sale of movable or immovable property |
|
Disposal of proceeds of sale of goods and movable or immovable property |
|
Attachment of debt and shares, etc. |
|
Recovery from surety |
|
Payment of tax and other amount in instalments |
|
--Who can allow payment of amount due in instalments |
|
--No permission in respect of liability self-assessed in return |
|
--Default in payment of any one instalment--Consequences of |
|
--Form of application |
|
--No permission for payment of tax in instalment in certain cases |
|
Transfer of property to be void in certain cases |
|
Tax to be first charge on property |
|
Continuation and validation of certain recovery proceedings |
77. |
Provisional Attachment to Protect Interest of Revenue |
|
Objective behind provisional attachment of property or bank account |
|
Provisions applicable upto 31-12-2021 |
|
Provisions applicable w.e.f. 1-1-2022 |
|
Implication of amendments made by the Finance Act, 2021 |
|
Officer empowered to order provisional attachment |
|
Formation of opinion must be based on some credible material |
|
Scope of power to attach property provisionally |
|
Mechanical exercise of power under section 83 should stop |
|
Provisional attachment to cease to expire after expiry of one year |
|
Fresh order of attachment can be passed after expiry of one year |
|
No notice issued within six months of attached |
|
No any proceeding pending against assessee--Validity of provisional attachment |
|
No provisional attachment allowed during pendency of proceeding u/s 71 |
|
Provisional attachment to cease to exist where proceeding is over |
|
Attachment of cash credit account is not sustanable |
|
Attachment of stock of goods and current account not sustainable |
|
No cogent or credible evidence on record |
|
No provisional attachment to be ordered in case revenue neutral situation |
|
Delegation of authority not permissible |
|
Assessee did not file objection--Validity of provisional attachment |
|
Mere pendency of proceeding under section 67 is not sufficient |
|
Bank account of ex-director cannot be attached for fault of company |
|
Assessee involved in issuance of bogus/fake inovices |
|
Procedure to be followed for making provisional attachment |
78. |
Offences Relating to Fake Invoices, Prosecution and Arrest |
|
Offences relating to issuance of fake invoices |
|
Issuing any invoice or bill without supply of goods or services |
|
Availing input tax credit on the basis of fake invoice or bill |
|
Producing fake accounts and records |
|
Dealing with goods liable to confiscation |
|
Dealing with supply of services in contravention of the provisions of the Act |
|
Attempting to commit or abeting commission of any offences |
|
Punishment specified under the Act |
|
Minimum term of imprisonment |
|
Meaning of arrest |
|
Arrest without adjudication of demand is not sustainable |
|
Conditions precedent for arrest |
|
Procedure for arrest |
|
Who is authorised to arrest any person? |
|
Authorised officer to inform the grounds of offence |
|
Powers to grant bail or other powers in case of non-cognizable and bailable offence |
|
Safeguards provided for a person who is placed under arrest |
|
Cases where bail was granted |
|
Cases where bail was not granted |
|
Arrest memo |
|
Modalities to be complied with at the time of arrest |
|
Applicability of provisions of Code of Criminal Procedure |
|
Cognizable offence--Meaning and nature |
|
--Meaning of cognizable offence |
|
--Which offence are cognizable offences |
|
--No Court can take cognizance of any offence without permission of designated authority |
|
Meaning of non-cognizable offence |
|
Presumption of culpable mental status |
|
Relevancy of statements under certain circumstances |
|
Invoice realted offences by companies and certain other persons |
|
Compounding of offences |
|
--Compounding of offences by Competent Authority |
|
--Compounding would not affect proceedings under any other law |
|
--Minimum and maximum amount of compounding amount |
|
--No further proceedings to be intiated on payment of compounding amount |
|
Procedure for compounding of offences |
|
Part IV--Overview of Tax Invoices, Bill of Supply, Credit Notes and Debit Notes |
79. |
Issuance of Tax Invoice, Bill of Supply, Debit Notes and Credit Notes |
|
Tax invoice for supply of taxable goods |
|
Tax invoice for supply of taxable services |
|
Time limit for issuance of tax invoice, bill of supply, etc. |
|
Continuous supply of goods--Meaning |
|
Continuous supply of services--Meaning |
|
Cases, where tax invoice or bill of supply is not required to be issued |
|
Issue of tax invoice and payment voucher by a person paying tax under RCM |
|
Details required to be contained on a tax invoice |
|
No signature required in case of issuance of invoice electornically |
|
Format of tax invoice |
|
Additional details to be mentioned in case of exports |
|
Requirement of mentioning HSN code in tax invoice |
|
Amount of tax is to be indicated in tax invoice |
|
No need to record Aadhaar or PAN of customer |
|
Expenses like freight/transport/packing should be mentioned in tax invoice |
|
Tools may be sent on the basis of delivery challan |
|
Tax invoice or bill of supply to accompany transport of goods |
|
Manner of issuing invoice |
|
Issuance of tax invoice in special cases |
|
Use of single bill book for supply of both goods or services |
|
Issue of receipt voucher and refund voucher |
|
Issuance of revised tax invoice |
|
Bill of supply |
|
Invoice-cum-bill of supply |
|
Issuance of invoice by recipient of goods or services in certain cases |
|
Issuance of credit notes |
|
Particulars required to be contained in a credit note |
|
Adjustment of tax liability |
|
Declaration of details of credit note in monthly return |
|
Issuance of debit notes |
|
Particulars required to be contained on a debit note |
|
Additional tax liability |
|
Declaration of details of debit notes in monthly return |
|
Issuance of ISD invoice or ISD credit note by an Input Service Distributor |
|
Tax invoice in case of an insurer or a banking company or a financial institution |
|
Issuance of tax invoice by a goods transport agency |
|
Issuance of tax invoice by any person engaged in passenger transport service |
|
Invoice or debit note issued in pursuance of tax payable in accordance with provisions of sections 74 or 129 or 130 |
|
Issuance of delivery challan |
|
APPENDIX |
|
Specimen of Tax Invoice |
|
Specimen of Bill of Supply |
|
Specimen of Export Invoice |
|
Receipt Voucher (Specimen) |
|
Payment Voucher (Specimen) |
|
Refund Voucher (Specimen) |
|
Debit Note (Specimen) |
|
Credit Note/Revised Invoice (Specimen) |
80. |
E-Invoice |
|
Need of E-invoicing |
|
What is e-invoice? |
|
Persons required to prepare e-invoice |
|
Persons not required to prepare e-invoice |
|
Types of documents to be prepared electornically |
|
Types of transactions for which generation of e-invoice not required |
|
Common portal for issuance of e-invoice |
|
Redressel of grievance |
|
Obtaining Invoice Reference Number for certain period |
|
Contents of an E-Invoice |
|
Ingredients of IRN |
|
Cancellation of E-Invoice |
|
Amendment of IRN |
|
Benefits of e-invoicing |
|
Consequences of non-preparation of E-invoice |
81. |
Tax Invoice and QR Code |
|
Tax invoice to contain QR code |
|
No requirement of QR code for supplies made to exports |
|
Invoices issued by what persons not required to have QR Code? |
|
Details required to be captured in QR Code |
|
Customer opting to make payment without QR Code |
|
Where Dynamic QR Code not displayed on electronic mode of payment |
|
Payment made before issuance of invoice |
|
Supplier using e-commerce portal for supplies--Requirement of QR Code |
|
Penalty for faiure to comply with QR Code requirement |
|
Waiver of penalty for failure to comply with requirement of having QR Code |
82. |
Input Tax Credit Vis-a-Vis Tax Invoice |
|
Statutory provisions governing input tax credit |
|
Taking of input tax credit |
|
Conditions for taking input tax credit |
|
Receipt of goods or services |
|
--Goods or services must have been received |
|
--When is goods or services are deemed to be received |
|
--Where goods are received in instalment |
|
Value of supply and tax is paid to supplier within 180 days |
|
--Statutory provisions |
|
--ITC can be re-claimed after making payment |
|
--Value of supply between distinct persons is deemed to be paid |
|
--Amount which a supplier is liable to pay in relation to supply is deemed to be received |
|
--No reversal required where consideration is paid through book adjustment |
|
Reversal of credit where tax is not paid by supplier |
|
--Statutory provision |
|
--Reversal of input tax credit |
|
--Department should first enquire seller |
|
--Omission on part of selling dealer to remit tax not relevant |
|
--Department should show connivance of purchasing dealer and selling dealer |
|
--Buyers cannot be put in jeopardy when he has done all the law requires |
|
--Supplier filed GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B in November of next financial year |
|
Restriction on availment of ITC in respect of invoices/debit notes not reflected in Form 2A [Position upto 31-12-2021] |
|
--The restriction |
|
--ITC not covered by restriction under rule 36(4) |
|
--Cummulative application of rule 36(4) |
|
--CBIC clarification |
|
Restriction on availment of ITC as per new rule 37(4) |
|
Restriction on use of amount available in electronic credit ledger |
|
Availing of input tax by recipient |
|
No ITC allowable where demand has been confirmed on account of fraud, etc. |
|
Cross utilization of ITC between two firms located in another State not allowable |
|
Where goods have been delivered to a person other than taxable person |
|
Where services are provided by the supplier on direction of other person |
|
Taking of input tax credit by non-resident |
|
Documents required for claiming input tax credit |
|
Documents must contain prescribed particulars |
|
Order of utilization of input tax credit |
|
Maximum time limit for claiming input tax credit |
|
--Position effective upto 31-12-2020 |
|
--Position effective from 1-1-2021 to 31-03-2022 |
|
--Position effective from 1-4-2022 |
|
--Provision illustrated |
|
--ITC relating to FY 2017-18 could be availed till due date of furnishing GSTR-1 of March, 2019 |
|
--No time limit for re-availment of credit, reversed earlier |
|
No input tax credit allowable if depreciation is claimed on tax component |
|
Input tax credit on capital goods is allowable in one instalment |
|
Transfer of credit on obtaining separate registration for multiple places of business within a State or Union Territory |
83. |
Input Tax Credit Vis-a-Vis Job Work |
|
Procedure for removal of inputs or capital goods for job work |
|
Principal is allowed to take input tax credit on inputs sent to job-worker |
|
Inputs sent for job-work, not received back within prescribed period--Consequences of |
|
Input tax credit on capital goods sent to a job-worker |
|
Capital goods--Meaning ofqa1 |
|
Input tax credit is allowable even on capital goods sent directly to a job worker |
|
Capital goods not received back within three years--Consequences of |
|
Conditions and restriction in respect of inputs and capital goods sent to job worker |
|
--Goods to be sent under cover of a challan |
|
--Details required to be contained in challan |
|
--Details of challan to furnished in FORM GST ITC-04 |
84. |
Input Service Distributor |
|
Concept of input service distributor |
|
Input service distributor--Defined |
|
Registration as ISD |
|
Filing of return by ISD |
|
Manner of distribution of credit by ISD |
|
Reduction of amount of input tax credit--Consequences of |
|
Furnishing of details of ISD credit note in Form GSTR-6 |
|
Conditions to be satisfied for distribution of input tax credit |
|
Relevant period--Definition |
|
Recipient of credit--Defined |
|
Turnover--Defined |
|
Details required to be contained in an ISD invoice or an ISD credit note |
|
Details required to be contained in a credit or debit note to transfer credit of common input services to Input Service Distributor |
|
Manner of recovery of credit distributed in excess |
|
Transitional provisions in respect of distribution of service tax credit |
|
Penalty for distribution of credit wrongly |
85. |
Recording of Tax Invoices and Bill of Supply |
|
Records required to be maintained by a registered taxable person |
|
Other records and accounts |
|
Maintaining accounts of stock |
|
Maintaining account of advances received, paid and adjustments made thereto |
|
Accounts of invoices issued/received, input tax credit, output tax, tax paid, etc. |
|
Maintaining particulars of suppliers, customers and godown, etc. |
|
Levy of tax on goods found at non-declared godown or warehouse |
|
Place where accounts and records are required to be maintained |
|
--Accounts are to be maintained at principal place |
|
--Accounting relating to each place of business to be maintained separately |
|
--Documents, registers, etc, found at other place |
|
Special procedure for maintenance of records by a principal or auctioneer |
|
Maintenance of records i.r.o. goods sent out of India for exhibition |
|
Keeping and maintaining accounts and records in electronic form |
|
Permission to certain class of persons to maintain accounts in other manner |
|
Record of correction or deletion of entry |
|
Each volume of books of account to be serially numbered |
|
Accounts required to be maintained by an agent |
|
Manufacturers are required to maintain monthly production accounts |
|
Specific records required to be maintained by supplier of services |
|
Specific records required to be maintained by a registered person executing works contract |
|
Records to be maintained by a carrier or a clearing and forwarding agent |
|
Enrolment of owner or operator of godown or warehouse |
|
Issuance of unique common enrolment number to a transporter |
|
Records to be maintained by a transporter |
|
Records to be maintained by owner or operator of warehouse or godown |
|
Period of retention of accounts |
|
--Period of retention of accounts in normal cases |
|
--Period of retention of accounts in cases involving appeal, revision, etc. |
|
Failure to account for goods or services or both--Consequence of |
|
Defaults relating to books of account--Consequences of |
|
--Imposition of penalty |
|
--Prosecution |
86. |
E-Way Bill and Invoices |
|
Documents to be carried by a person-in-charge of a conveyance |
|
Requirement of carrying invoice in case of issaunce of e-invoice |
|
Generation of e-way bill |
|
E-way bill may be generated even for lesser value |
|
Where value of goods is not known at the time of supply |
|
Consignment value--Meaning of |
|
--Consignment value includes tax |
|
--Value of exempt supply of goods not included |
|
--E-way bill is required to be issued for each consignment |
|
Cases, where e-way bill is required to be generated irrespective of value of consignment |
|
--Inter-State transport of goods by a principal to job worker place |
|
--Inter-State transport of handicraft goods by an exempted person |
|
Cases, where e-way bill is not required to be generated |
|
Tax invoice or bill of supply to accompany transport of goods |
|
Restriction on generation of e-way bill |
|
Documents/devices to be carried by a person-in-charge of a conveyance |
|
--Documents to be carried by a person-in-charge of a conveyance |
|
--Obtaining Invoice Reference Number from common portal |
|
--Certain class of transporters are required to obtain a unique Radio Frequency Identification Device |
|
Non-issuance of e-way bill--Consequences of |
|
E-way bill may be generated even for lesser value |
|
Movement of goods by unregistered person |
|
Validity period of consolidated e-way bill |
|
Multiple invoices belonging to same consignor and consignee cannot be clubbed |
|
Entering multiple modes of transportation for same e-way bill |
|
Validity period of e-way bill |
|
--Basis of calculation of validity period |
|
--Relevant date--Meaning |
|
--Over Dimensional Cargo--Meaning |
|
Extension of validity period of e-way bill |
|
--Power of Commissioner to extend validity period of e-way bill |
|
--Extension of validity period of e-way bill by transporter |
|
Starting point of validity of e-way bill |
|
Basis of calculation of validity period |
|
Relevant date--Meaning |
|
Over Dimensional Cargo--Meaning |
|
Validity period is to be checked in respect of individual e-way bill |
|
Calculation of distance in case of import or export of goods |
|
Extension of validity period of e-way bill |
|
Change of vehicle due to accident or break down--Consequence of |
|
Maximum distance that can be mentioned in an E-way bill |
|
Generation of e-way bill in case of Ex-Factory sale |
|
Generation of Part-A Slip |
|
Furnishing of Part-A where consignor or consignee is not having GSTIN |
|
Furnishing of information in Part-B is mandatory |
|
Updation of Part-B by transporter |
|
Cases where furnishing of Part-B (vehicle detail) is not required |
|
Updation of Part-B by other transporter |
|
Updation of Part-B in case of change of vehicle |
|
Updation of Part-B in case of multimodal transport of goods |
|
Updation of Part-B in case of vehicle break down |
|
Part-B is required to be updated for each movement in a trans-shipment |
|
Transportation of goods through multiple modes of transportation |
|
Formats of vehicle number entry |
|
Transfer of goods from one conveyance to another |
|
Assignment of e-way bill number for further movement of consignment |
|
Furnishing of details of e-way bill in FORM GSTR-1 |
|
Movement of goods from one unit of the company to another unit |
|
E-way bill can be generated from different registered place of business |
|
E-way bill cannot be generated from a unregistered location |
|
Transport of goods from place of business of transporter to final destination |
|
Generating e-way bill in case of 'Bill to' - 'Ship to' invoice |
|
Generation of e-way bill for "Bill from" - "Dispatch from" invoice |
|
Multiple invoices belonging to same consignor and consignee cannot be clubbed |
|
Where goods of one invoice is being moved in multiple vehicles simultaneously |
|
Generation of E-way bill in case of High Sea sale transactions |
|
Movement of goods from Customs port to warehouse |
|
Multiple invoices cannot be clubbed in one E-way bill |
|
Goods of smaller value belonging to one consignor loaded in a single vehicle |
|
Supply of goods to SEZ |
|
Sending of goods for weightment outside factory |
|
Change in ownership of goods in the course of transporatation |
|
Generation of e-way bill in case of Ex-Factory sale |
|
Generation of e-way bill in case of FOR sale |
|
Manufacturer having multiples places of business within a State |
|
Movement of tools to customer's place |
|
Consequence of non-generation of e-way bill |